Plane wave approximation

Question

Consider a proton in harmonic motion along vertical direction.

http://physics.weber.edu/schroeder/mrr/MRRtalk.html

Near a point source, direction of electric field is along the curve.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plane_wave

But at greater distance from point source, in plane wave approximation, electric field is not along the sinusoid but it is perpendicular to axis.

How the direction of electric field is determined in plane wave approximation?

Answer 1

The electric field of an oscillating point charge consists of a Coulombic component and a radiative component:

• the Coulombic part is generally directed away from the charge, and it goes down as $1/r^2$ with the distance from the center of the oscillations.
• the radiative part is generally transversely polarized, and it goes down as $1/r$ with the distance from the charge.

When we're considering radiation, we keep the $1/r$ component, because it dominates completely over the $1/r^2$ Coulombic near-field when you're far away from the charge. This explains the discrepancy you observe.

As to how the direction of the electric field is determined - that obviously depends on the situation. Plane waves are a model, and nothing more, and they are generally a terrible model for the field radiated by a point charge. (Instead, you normally use spherical EM waves.) Different situations call for different models, and different characteristics of the radiation within those models.