2
$\begingroup$

I've looked many related answers on the Internet but found little. The coin is rolling on the floor, it's not spinning. The questions are: why does it start to move in circles and what is the minimum angular velocity (dimensionally determined) for it to start this kind of trajectory.

One possible explanation that I tried is that, as it slows down due to the ground friction and starts to incline, there is a torque due to g acting perpendicularly to the angular moment and determining a centripetal force.

Any help is welcome!

$\endgroup$
0

1 Answer 1

1
$\begingroup$

At first, coin is spinning in own fixed reference frame (along axis which goes through the center of coin). So given this fact, it not differs much from spinning humming-top rotated by $90^{\circ}$. Both systems would be stable due to angular momentum conservation $\vec L = \vec r \times \vec p = \text{const}$, if no dissipation forces would be acting upon them (such as friction).

why does it start to move in circles

It's because gravity on coin COM, which has slope $\theta \gt 0$ from ground normal, induces centripetal acceleration.

what is the minimum angular velocity (dimensionally determined) for it to start this kind of trajectory

Very good question. At particular time $t$ coin moves in a trajectory with a curvature radius $R$ defined as : $$ R = \frac {v^2}{g \sin \theta} $$

Where $v$,- coin tangential speed along trajectory curvature point. So from formula it can be seen that when coin acquires inclination angle $\theta \gt 0$ - it instantly starts to move along some curvature, with radius $R$. Coin can move technically in a straight line if and only if inclination angle from ground normal $\theta = 0$. (Put zero angle in a formula, and you'll get $R=\infty$, that's a metrics for a straight line.

As about experimental coin movement patterns,- there can be some distinct cases, as pictured below :

enter image description here

In case A) coin acquires random micro inclinations from ground normal and starts fluctuating in a repeating patterns of curvature radius $[-R,R]$. In B) variant coin starting inclination is zero, so it initially moves in a straight line, but as it approaches zero speed, instantly random inclination is amplified by gravity and system collapses. In the last C) case initial speed is great and coin also has an initial non-zero inclination, so it starts to move in a spiral - with gradually decreasing curvature radius.

So the final answer is that coin will begin to move in a curved-way, when it will acquire inclination angle. Now, if you would ask when or in what conditions it will have inclination angle greater than zero - the answer is I don't know. This may depend on bunch of unknown factors, such as initial speed of coin, surface static and dynamic friction coefficients, air drag force, cross-section of coin, did or did not coin had an initial inclination angle (i.e. you gave it yourself by pushing coin), and etc.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.