# Feynman's disk paradox used as a gyroscope?

I have recently learned about Feynman's disk paradox, where angular momentum is stored in the properties of the electric field. One example would be a coil with current going through whose axis is shared with a disk carrying charges on its edges. As long as the current flows through the coil the disk is motionless, but as soon as it is turned off the disk starts spinning due to the change in the magnetic field exacting a force on the charges. The explanation that I have heard why this does not violate the conservation of angular momentum is that angular momentum is stored in the electric field. So far so good.

What I dont understand is the following scenario: Suppose you were to use the contraption as described as a gyroscope: Start with a spinning disc with high angular momentum. Now stp this disc with a strong electro magnet. Assume they are both fixed to the same steel rod. Now as long as the no current is flowing and the disc is spinning it is very hard to topple the device due to precession. But as soon as the electricity is flowing there should be no more precession(?) and you can topple the device and switch the electricity off again and have the disk spinning.

Obviously that cannot happen because you would have changed the angular momentum completely with very little torque. So my question is what happens when I would try to do that?

Edit: Here a simple illustration of what I try to do:

– user163104
Aug 13, 2017 at 17:19
• Can you add a diagram - it is not clear to me what you are doing here. Clearly angular momentum should be conserved - and if angular momentum is conserved, a gyroscope will continue to act as a gyroscope. Aug 13, 2017 at 21:22
• Added a diagram. It is clear to me that angular momentum is conserved, I want to know what happens precisely on the level of forces, if possible. Aug 13, 2017 at 21:59
• @Floris When the current is turned on, the system stops spinning. It is just a stationary electromagnet (surrounded by the ring of charge). You rotate the axis 180 degrees . Then turn the current off and it spins with the opposite angular momentum. So, the question is, can you do the rotation without imparting any angular momentum? Aug 14, 2017 at 4:22
• The answer may be here. Aug 14, 2017 at 4:29