I know that water with salts is a good conductor-However wetting a hand only adds water to a not very conductive surface. How does water actually reduce the resistance of skin? The way I am seeing it is that as opposed to just a wire touching skin, the wire is touching water then touching skin, which still does not seem to imply we would have less resistance.
-
$\begingroup$ How are you testing this? Are the two wires touching the same patch of wet skin? If so the current will take the path of least resistance which is the water on the surface of the skin. $\endgroup$– WillCommented Jun 9, 2013 at 23:57
-
$\begingroup$ Even if it's just two wet patches that are isolated, can't it kill you? $\endgroup$– user24082Commented Jun 10, 2013 at 5:35
-
$\begingroup$ I'm not sure how that is an answer to my question. $\endgroup$– WillCommented Jun 11, 2013 at 4:25
2 Answers
Salt water conducts electricity because it has mobile electrons and ionic states via the salt atoms, and dry protein of your skin is an insulator which has less reactive molecules than salt ions. Salt water provides a large surface area of contact for the conductive element and it connects with the sweat glands so electricity can flow past the skin and into your body, which has low electrical resistance.
First of all, don't try this at home.
You may consider your body as a resistive element (with total resistance about 1000 Ohms). This depends on personal parameters, given voltage and many other factors, but let's say it's around that. It is your total (equivalent) resistance, but each part of body has it's own, but combining them together will lead to this ca. 1 kOhm.
If you touch a wire, the current flows through the body. There is a voltage drop on it, so you calculate current dividing voltage by your body, if you are still able to ;-).
When you are wet, water makes a surface on your skin. This is equivalent to connect your body with this water surface in parallel. The total resistance of your body and water connected in parallel is smaller, but current through the body itself does not change, but it is larger in total as some flows through water. Some electricians still believe that keeping hand in pocket while touching a wire with the other hand, in case of failure, will make current flow through the hand in pocket and bypassing the heart. This is very hard to prove, however.
For example, let's consider you have wet arm from fingers to a shoulder. If it is wet, you add water in parallel and thus lower resistance of arm. So shoulder has higher potential than it would had in case of dry arm. This means that larger current flows through your heart.
But --
Current can in some part lower body resistance: because water tends to flow under your skin, which is not a solid barrier. This might be because of energy of the flowing current, increasing the temperature, and making some dielectric phenomena on the cellular level, that destroy skin surface.
All these things apply to some high voltage, say 200 V and more. If you touch 24 V with a wet hand, you probably will not see the difference.
To read more about human body resistivity, you might like to read this article. Please notice (Table 1) that fat has much larger resistivity than other organs. Your skin has always fat on it and it is used by criminal police to find fingerprints. If it is wet, the fat surface could be thinner.
-
1$\begingroup$ This answer sounds reasonable (i.e. that the area of connexion with the wire is raised). However (speculation on my part here), I wouldn't be surprised if part of the effect is that water dissolves ions and electrolytes in the skin, thus reinforcing what Voitcus is saying. $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 28, 2013 at 11:13
-
$\begingroup$ Well, yes, some osmotic changes within salt of skin can occur, but I don't know the impact of this. $\endgroup$– VoitcusCommented Jun 28, 2013 at 12:35
-
1$\begingroup$ This is an old question, but I have one thing to add. The reason for "one hand in the pocket" is that it prevents you from directly touching a ground with one hand and a live wire with the other. If you're wearing rubber-soled shoes, there's a pretty good chance that you're not going to electrocute yourself nearly as badly as you would by touching a 120V live with one hand and the neutral with the other (which will flow straight across your heart) $\endgroup$ Commented May 15, 2015 at 3:35
-
$\begingroup$ skeptics.stackexchange.com/a/9715/11686 has a better answer, most of the time you are replacing an air gap with salty water between the body and the wire, not running a parallel circuit of water. $\endgroup$– danielCommented Oct 30, 2017 at 14:43
-
$\begingroup$ ' If it is wet, you add water in parallel and thus lower resistance of arm. So shoulder has higher potential than it would had in case of dry arm. This means that larger current flows through your heart.' But what if the whole body was wet, for example you just got out of a swimming pool or a shower? And don't the clothes have an additional effect on this? $\endgroup$– satoCommented Dec 29, 2020 at 6:59