So I'm reading Sean Carroll's old blog post:
But to a modern physicist, this seems like a misguided quest. First, because renormalization theory teaches us that $\alpha$ isn’t really a number at all; it’s a function. In particular, it’s a function of the total amount of momentum involved in the interaction you are considering. Essentially, the strength of electromagnetism is slightly different for processes happening at different energies. Atiyah isn’t even trying to derive a function, just a number.
This is basically the objection given by Sabine Hossenfelder. But to be as charitable as possible, I don’t think it’s absolutely a knock-down objection. There is a limit we can take as the momentum goes to zero, at which point $\alpha$ is a single number.
I'm kind of rusty in QFT but can someone give me a heuristic reasoning to the lines:
it’s a function of the total amount of momentum involved in the interaction you are considering
And
There is a limit we can take as the momentum goes to zero, at which point $\alpha$ is a single number.