Why M-theory has only M2 and M5 branes? In string theory, depending on the type one considers, you get all kind of D-branes. What is so special in M-theory that only allows 2 and 5 branes?


2 Answers 2


The type of branes a theory has in constrained by the p-form fields it contains. There is only one supersymmetric gravity theory in 11d, and it has a single $p$-form with $p=4$, call it $G_4$. This means that the theory can possess brane solutions that either couple electrically to $G_4$ (M2 branes) or magnetically to $G_4$ (M5 branes).

To understand the dimensionality of an electric coupling, The $p$-form field corresponds to a $p-1$-form potential. $p-2$ of these directions correspond to the extended brane directions (if there are any), and the last one corresponds to time. Compare this with the familiar case of electromagnetism where $A_t$ couples electrically to a point particle's worldline, and the field strength is $F_2 = dA$. In the case of M-theory, this means that $G_4$ couples electrically to a two-dimensional object, i.e. M2 branes.

To see where the magnetic M5 branes come about, simple take the Hodge dual to obtain a 7-form: $\star G_4 = G_7$, and then $G_7$ couples (by the same arithmetic as above) to a 5-brane, i.e. M5 branes.

Oh, and just a comment, in the 10D string theories there are indeed many different branes, but not all kinds. They are constrained by the same counting. So for example, in terms of D-branes (not counting the NS branes), IIB only has odd-dimension branes and IIA has even ones.


In supergravity theory, 11d have 3 dimensional scalar object and 6 dimensional anti-symmetric tensor object. This allows that M-theory have M2 brane and M5 brane only.

(By studying on the following question, D branes Ns brane and p-branes, I found some interesting paper: Supermembranes, arXiv:hep-th/9611203. It seems to me that section "1.3 The brane scan" describes relevant information on this question. So I post it here. This review paper also covers other various dimensions such as 10d,9d, $\cdots$ up to 2d)


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.