Skip to main content
added 527 characters in body
Source Link
Roger V.
  • 65.1k
  • 7
  • 69
  • 215

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snowflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

Update
As the diagram given in the @JohnDumancic answer below demonstrates, snow crystals grow in the form of plates at temperatures from 0 to $-3^\circ$C or below $-10^\circ$. The question is thus essentially reduced to the typical conditions (temperature and water vapour saturation) that exist in the snow clouds.

As noted in the comments, snow crystals galling from the sky are not always flat - so information on whether flat snowflakes are specific only to certain geographic regions could be also relevant.

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snowflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snowflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

Update
As the diagram given in the @JohnDumancic answer below demonstrates, snow crystals grow in the form of plates at temperatures from 0 to $-3^\circ$C or below $-10^\circ$. The question is thus essentially reduced to the typical conditions (temperature and water vapour saturation) that exist in the snow clouds.

As noted in the comments, snow crystals galling from the sky are not always flat - so information on whether flat snowflakes are specific only to certain geographic regions could be also relevant.

Notice removed Canonical answer required by Roger V.
Bounty Ended with John Dumancic's answer chosen by Roger V.
deleted 89 characters in body
Source Link
Urb
  • 2.7k
  • 4
  • 14
  • 26

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., herehere and herehere. There is however one aspect of snoflakessnowflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snoflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snowflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackPhysics/status/1353719305976901632
Notice added Canonical answer required by Roger V.
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Roger V.
GRAMMAR NAZI didn't like the wording :)
Source Link
DanielC
  • 4.4k
  • 2
  • 23
  • 39

Why snowflakes are snowflakes flat?

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snoflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why snoflakes are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phasephases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest isare destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

Why snowflakes are flat?

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snoflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why snoflakes are flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phase. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest is destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure, but polished while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

Why are snowflakes flat?

There have been many questions and excellent answers in this community about the symmetry of snowflakes, e.g., here and here. There is however one aspect of snoflakes that does not seem clearly addressed: Why are snowflakes flat?

  • One reason could be the crystallization conditions during the snowflake formation, which favor certain crystalline phases. Somewhat similarly to how carbon can crystallize into graphite, i.e., weakly connected graphene sheets ("a snowflake phase") and diamond (and a bunch of more complex forms), depending on the pressure, temperature, etc.
  • Another possibility is a selection of flat forms as the snowflakes move through the atmosphere, while the rest are destroyed.
  • Finally, the snowflakes may be really having a 3D structure upon formation, but polished (flattened) while moving through the atmosphere.

I am looking for answers based on credible scientific sources.

edited tags
Link
Qmechanic
  • 213.1k
  • 48
  • 590
  • 2.3k
Loading
Source Link
Roger V.
  • 65.1k
  • 7
  • 69
  • 215
Loading