4
$\begingroup$

enter image description here

I have read these questions:

Do gravitational lenses work on gravitational waves?

Are gravitational waves effected by the curvature of space time (gravitational lensing)?

And it made me curious.

I understand that gravitons and gravitational waves are not the same thing.

But this question here:

Gravitons unaffected by gravitational lensing?

It is talking about LIGO experiment and that we detect gravitons by that experiment. And it says that so gravitons do cause gravity and bend spacetime.

So from this question it is not understandable whether LIGO experiment is detecting gravitational waves or gravitons and whether gravitons themselves cause bending of spacetime. I would think they do not, because it is stress energy that bends spacetime.

So it is not understandable whether gravitons are mediating the bending of spacetime, in which case the Sun would shadow most of these effects (depending on whether gravitons are effected by gravitational lensing).

Or is it that it is stress energy that bends spacetime and it does not matter whether the Sun shadows these effects (the Sun is inbetween a far away star and the Earth) or not, the bending of spacetime (from a far away star) still reaches us regardless whether the Sun is there or not.

Imagine there is a star at point A far away from Earth, where Earth is point B, and inbetween the Sun.

We know as per GR that there is gravitational lensing (of photons) because of the Sun's gravitational field. The Sun's stress energy bends spacetime and the photons coming from the far away star are traveling along a bent path.

None of the questions says anything about gravitons following a geodesic or gravitons being affected by bent spacetime.

They did not say anything about the Earth being affected by the gravitational effects of a far away star that would be behind the Sun.

In this case, when a far away star is behind the Sun, I do not know whether the far away star's gravitational effects are still reaching Earth or does the Sun shadow these effects?

I did not find anything whether the Earth itself would be shadowed (gravitationally) by the Sun as an object. And I did not find anything whether gravitons from this far away star would still reach us (like photons do).

Questions:

  1. Do gravitons travel along geodesics, and do they travel along bent spacetime? Is my graph correct with the graviton's path being bent like a photon's path?

  2. If a far away star is behind the Sun, but we still see it (photons still reach us from there) because of gravitational lensing, then do gravitons (and other effects of gravity) reach us from that far away star too?

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

We still don't know if gravitons really exist. We need a proper theory of Quantum Gravity for that. Of course, in a sense, no particles really exist, they're just a convenient way to model the excitations of quantum fields.

Individual gravitons are far too weak to be detectable with current technology, LIGO can only detect big gravitational waves. It's like the difference between being able to detect a big water wave vs detecting the motion of single water molecules. Or the difference between being able to detect strong light vs single photons.

Yes, gravitons (if they exist) follow geodesics, just like everything else does, so they would be subject to gravitational lensing. One big difference with photons is that gravity isn't blocked by anything, so stars are transparent to gravitons. I don't know how black holes fit into the picture.

Another important difference to photons (which has been mentioned in the comments) is that gravitons carry gravitational charge, purely because they carry energy. So in a way they're more like gluons, the carriers of the strong nuclear interaction, rather than being like photons. However, there's only one type of gravitational charge, unlike the various colors associated with gluons.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Gravitons are hypothetical quanta of gravitational fields. They are supposed to come from quantum description of gravity. So their relation with gravitational waves is analogous to the relation between photons and electromagnetic waves. But unlike photons, gravitons DO interact with themselves, which means, yes, they are affected by gravitational lensing.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Photons shouls interact with each other too no? $\endgroup$ – Árpád Szendrei Jun 27 '18 at 18:16
  • $\begingroup$ @ÁrpádSzendrei no, photons do not interact with each other in a conventional sense (they don't have an electric charge), although there is a subtlety about higher-order quantum corrections in QFT. $\endgroup$ – Kosm Jun 27 '18 at 18:21
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @ÁrpádSzendrei on the other hand, gravitons do carry gravitational charge - energy. $\endgroup$ – Kosm Jun 27 '18 at 18:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.