0
$\begingroup$

I'm confused about the following problem I encountered. Given a set $\Omega$, which has on its boundary $\partial\Omega$ a surface charge (per area) $q_0$, I want to show that $$\int_\Omega E^2=\int_\Omega \rho\Phi,$$ where $E$ is the electric field $E=-\nabla\Phi$, $\Phi$ the potential and $\nabla E=-\rho$, $\rho$ the charge density.

Here, $\rho = q_0\delta(\partial\Omega)$, where the $\delta$-distribution gives me the condition that the density is localized on the surface.

Now I need to be very clear that $\Omega\supseteq\partial\Omega$. Given this, lets start from the lhs and use $$\int_\Omega E^2=\int_\Omega (\nabla\Phi)^2=\int_{\partial\Omega}\vec{n}(\nabla \Phi)\Phi-\int_\Omega\Phi\nabla^2\Phi,$$ where in the second equality, I used Green's formula.

But now comes the problem. I can insert for the first term on the RHS $\nabla \Phi=-E$. Because of $\nabla E=-\rho$ we have $$\int_{\partial\Omega}\vec{n}E=-\int_\Omega\rho=-\int_{\partial\Omega}q_0.$$ Now suppose our problem is symmetric, such that all quantities are constant on $\partial\Omega$ (e.g. a sphere).

This implies then: $\vec{n}E=-q_0$.

On the other hand, the second term reads $-\int_\Omega\Phi\nabla^2\Phi=\int_\Omega\Phi\rho$. Again using the fact the charge is localized on the surface, our equation reads $$\int_\Omega E^2=-\int_{\partial\Omega}q_0\Phi+\int_\Omega\rho\Phi=0$$

What am I doing wrong here? Normally, the boundary terms drops out since we assume $\Phi=0$ on the boundary. But here, without that assumption, it seems to break this relation (the first one I wrote) completely. Is there some argument why the Dirichlet boundary condition is natural?

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ I notice perhaps this question is a non-question. I think for a sphere, the electric field inside is just zero, something which can be proven precisely this way. And for more complicated geometries, the condition of constant charge may fail (or if I impose this to be true, then this automatically implies the field is 0?) $\endgroup$ Commented Sep 26 at 8:48

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.