0
$\begingroup$

A gas tank is divided into two parts by a stationary barrier. The tank is held at constant temperature and constant pressure. A small hole is pierced in the barrier, so that particles can move. Show that $\mu_1=\mu_2$.

Before looking at the solution, I used minimization of $F(T,V,N)$, Helmholtz Free Energy, since I know $T$ is constant and $V$ is constant for each side. I wrote $F_{tot}=F_1+F_2$ and diffrentiated with respect to $N_1$, the number of particles in the left side, which is the changing quantity in this case. I got the right result- $\mu_1=\mu_2$.

However, the solution used minimization of $G(T,P,N)$, Gibbs Free Energy, saying that both pressure and temperature are constant so this is the right thermodynamic potential to use.

I am insecure now- does my solution hold or is $G$ the only right thermodynamic potential for the problem? Did I miss anything? Did I get the right answer just by luck?

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

$F=F_1(T_1,V_1,N_1)+F_2(T_2,V_2,N_2)$. For constant temperature process,

$dF=dF_1+dF_2=-p_1 dV_1+\mu_1 dN_1-p_2 dV_2+\mu_2 dN_2=0$, at equilibrium.

Now $dN_1=-dN_2,p_1=p_2$, hence

$dF=-p_1 (dV_1+ dV_2)+(\mu_1 -\mu_2) dN_1=0$. Since $p_1(T_1,V_1,N_1)=$constant, in which $T_1$ is also constant, then $V_1$ must be a function of $N_1$. Therefore you cannot straight away equate the coefficient of $dN_1$ to zero to obtain $\mu_1=\mu_2$, because it is not an independent variation, i.e. variations $dV_1$ and $dV_2$ are not independent of $dN_1$. This dependence is a result of pressure being constant.

This problem is eliminated if you use $G$ instead, as you may verify yourself.

Reference: Thermodynamics by Callen.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.