Skip to main content
added 9 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Qmechanic
  • 213.1k
  • 48
  • 590
  • 2.3k

Charge conjugation of symplectic Majorana spinors in 54+1 dimensions

In the book "Supergravity" written by Freedman & van Proeyen, a symplectic Majorana spinor is defined in eq. (3.86)

$$ \chi^i = \varepsilon^{ij} (\chi^j)^C, $$$$ \chi^i = \varepsilon^{ij} (\chi^j)^C, \tag{3.86}$$

where the upper index $C$ denotes charge conjugation and $\varepsilon^{ij} \varepsilon_{kj} = \delta^i_k$.

Below the above equation in the book, there is an exercise asking one to show that, in five4+1 dimensions, given the symplectic Majorana spinors $\psi^i$ and $\chi^i$, the quantity $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is purely imaginary ($\overline{\psi}^i= (\psi^i)^T C$, with $C$ the charge conjugation matrix). I tried to show this last statement by doing the following computation

\begin{align} (\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji})^C &= (\overline{\psi}^i)^C (\chi^j)^C \varepsilon_{ji} \\ &=\varepsilon_{ki} \varepsilon_{lj} \overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \varepsilon_{ji} \\ & = \varepsilon_{lk}\overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \\ & = \overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}\,. \end{align}

Consequently, I get that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is real and not imaginary as the exercise states.

Is there a mistake in my computation? Or is the book statement that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ should be imaginary wrong?

Charge conjugation of symplectic Majorana spinors in 5 dimensions

In the book "Supergravity" written by Freedman & van Proeyen, a symplectic Majorana spinor is defined in eq. (3.86)

$$ \chi^i = \varepsilon^{ij} (\chi^j)^C, $$

where the upper index $C$ denotes charge conjugation and $\varepsilon^{ij} \varepsilon_{kj} = \delta^i_k$.

Below the above equation in the book, there is an exercise asking one to show that, in five dimensions, given the symplectic Majorana spinors $\psi^i$ and $\chi^i$, the quantity $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is purely imaginary ($\overline{\psi}^i= (\psi^i)^T C$, with $C$ the charge conjugation matrix). I tried to show this last statement by doing the following computation

\begin{align} (\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji})^C &= (\overline{\psi}^i)^C (\chi^j)^C \varepsilon_{ji} \\ &=\varepsilon_{ki} \varepsilon_{lj} \overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \varepsilon_{ji} \\ & = \varepsilon_{lk}\overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \\ & = \overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}\,. \end{align}

Consequently, I get that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is real and not imaginary as the exercise states.

Is there a mistake in my computation? Or is the book statement that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ should be imaginary wrong?

Charge conjugation of symplectic Majorana spinors in 4+1 dimensions

In the book "Supergravity" written by Freedman & van Proeyen, a symplectic Majorana spinor is defined in eq. (3.86)

$$ \chi^i = \varepsilon^{ij} (\chi^j)^C, \tag{3.86}$$

where the upper index $C$ denotes charge conjugation and $\varepsilon^{ij} \varepsilon_{kj} = \delta^i_k$.

Below the above equation in the book, there is an exercise asking one to show that, in 4+1 dimensions, given the symplectic Majorana spinors $\psi^i$ and $\chi^i$, the quantity $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is purely imaginary ($\overline{\psi}^i= (\psi^i)^T C$, with $C$ the charge conjugation matrix). I tried to show this last statement by doing the following computation

\begin{align} (\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji})^C &= (\overline{\psi}^i)^C (\chi^j)^C \varepsilon_{ji} \\ &=\varepsilon_{ki} \varepsilon_{lj} \overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \varepsilon_{ji} \\ & = \varepsilon_{lk}\overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \\ & = \overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}\,. \end{align}

Consequently, I get that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is real and not imaginary as the exercise states.

Is there a mistake in my computation? Or is the book statement that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ should be imaginary wrong?

Source Link
Slayer147
  • 1.1k
  • 10
  • 18

Charge conjugation of symplectic Majorana spinors in 5 dimensions

In the book "Supergravity" written by Freedman & van Proeyen, a symplectic Majorana spinor is defined in eq. (3.86)

$$ \chi^i = \varepsilon^{ij} (\chi^j)^C, $$

where the upper index $C$ denotes charge conjugation and $\varepsilon^{ij} \varepsilon_{kj} = \delta^i_k$.

Below the above equation in the book, there is an exercise asking one to show that, in five dimensions, given the symplectic Majorana spinors $\psi^i$ and $\chi^i$, the quantity $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is purely imaginary ($\overline{\psi}^i= (\psi^i)^T C$, with $C$ the charge conjugation matrix). I tried to show this last statement by doing the following computation

\begin{align} (\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji})^C &= (\overline{\psi}^i)^C (\chi^j)^C \varepsilon_{ji} \\ &=\varepsilon_{ki} \varepsilon_{lj} \overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \varepsilon_{ji} \\ & = \varepsilon_{lk}\overline{\psi}^k \chi^l \\ & = \overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}\,. \end{align}

Consequently, I get that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ is real and not imaginary as the exercise states.

Is there a mistake in my computation? Or is the book statement that $\overline{\psi}^i \chi^j \varepsilon_{ji}$ should be imaginary wrong?