Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackPhysics/status/1335146934269587456
Second iteration.
Source Link
Peter Mortensen
  • 2.4k
  • 2
  • 19
  • 25

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e., things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. 

To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs. B in a linear fit, and B vs. R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B = Ae-CR. Why is this?

Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project. I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e. things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs B in a linear fit, and B vs R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B = Ae-CR. Why is this?

Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project. I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e., things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. 

To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs. B in a linear fit, and B vs. R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B = Ae-CR. Why is this?

Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project. I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.

Copy edited. Superscript and subscript can be used as a poor man's MathJax.
Source Link
Peter Mortensen
  • 2.4k
  • 2
  • 19
  • 25

Why did I measure the magnetic field to vary exponentially with distance?

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e. things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs B in a linear fit, and B vs R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B=Ae^-CRB = Ae-CR. I can't figure out why thisWhy is this? 

Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project,. I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.

Why did I measure magnetic field to vary exponentially with distance?

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e. things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs B in a linear fit, and B vs R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B=Ae^-CR. I can't figure out why this is? Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project, I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.

Why did I measure the magnetic field to vary exponentially with distance?

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e. things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs B in a linear fit, and B vs R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B = Ae-CR. Why is this? 

Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project. I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.

Became Hot Network Question
Source Link
Peter Blood
  • 497
  • 4
  • 11

Why did I measure magnetic field to vary exponentially with distance?

In my physics lab class, we were allowed to come up with our own research question and then try to answer it. My question was whether permanent magnets (i.e. things like refrigerator magnets) would also have the characteristic that B decays with 1/distance as we see for the B created by current in a straight wire. To answer this, I measured the magnetic field using a magnetometer at various distances from the magnet and then plotted 1/R vs B in a linear fit, and B vs R in a semi-log and log-log fit. For all the fridge magnets studied, the chi-square value of the best fit line in the semi-log plot was much closer to 1 than in the other fits and the residuals were all near zero, indicating that the semi-log was the best fit (and not only the best fit, but a very good fit over all) and the relationship between B and R was best modeled by an equation of the form B=Ae^-CR. I can't figure out why this is? Why would permanent magnets have an exponential relationship with R? I don't need to know the answer to this question for my project, I just need to present the data, but I wondered if anybody knows why this might be.