Skip to main content
tried to make title/question better
Source Link
Qmechanic
  • 213.1k
  • 48
  • 590
  • 2.3k

Physical intuition for the Geodesic equationEquation derivation via Actiona Variational Principle: Why maximum proper time instead of minimum?

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that I can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized. (If the signature is $(+,-,-,-)$ it should be a maximum as some textbooks say.)

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I don't understand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead of a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space.

Physical intuition for the Geodesic equation derivation via Action Principle

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that I can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized. (If the signature is $(+,-,-,-)$ it should be a maximum as some textbooks say.)

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I don't understand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space.

Physical intuition for the Geodesic Equation derivation via a Variational Principle: Why maximum proper time instead of minimum?

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that I can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized.

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I don't understand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead of a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space.

added 6 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Qmechanic
  • 213.1k
  • 48
  • 590
  • 2.3k

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that iI can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized. ( IfIf the signature is (+,-,-,-)$(+,-,-,-)$ it should be a maximum as some textbooks say.)

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I dont undertanddon't understand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space.

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that i can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized ( If the signature is (+,-,-,-) it should be a maximum as some textbooks say)

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I dont undertand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that I can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized. (If the signature is $(+,-,-,-)$ it should be a maximum as some textbooks say.)

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I don't understand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space.

Source Link

Physical intuition for the Geodesic equation derivation via Action Principle

The most commom derivation I've seen of the geodesic equation of a massive particle is by the use of the Variational Principle. My problem is that i can't realize what the meaning of find a spacetime path (the geodesic) such that the proper time is extremized ( If the signature is (+,-,-,-) it should be a maximum as some textbooks say)

I understood that the action integral must be proportional to the line element $ds$ because we need that all the observers compute the same value of action to obtain the same equations of motion.

What I dont undertand is the physical meaning of finding a maximum proper time instead a minimum, and what physical implications it leads to. How can I conclude that what I need to find a geodesic equation is maximize proper time of the massive particle? If possible, make an analogy with the Minkowski Space