Skip to main content
Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by Jarek Duda
Bounty Ended with Ryan Thorngren's answer chosen by Jarek Duda
Improved diagram
Source Link
Jarek Duda
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 23

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value of classical function - period of such restricted ensemble (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description hereenter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value of classical function - period of such restricted ensemble (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value of classical function - period of such restricted ensemble (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Improve diagram
Source Link
Jarek Duda
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 23

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value value of classical function, which - period of such restricted ensemble (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description hereenter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value value of classical function, which period (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value of classical function - period of such restricted ensemble (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Tweeted twitter.com/StackPhysics/status/1220768376357904388
Notice added Authoritative reference needed by Jarek Duda
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Jarek Duda
Improved diagram and description
Source Link
Jarek Duda
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 23

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value value of classical function, which period (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description hereenter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work?Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv):

enter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Quantum mechanics is equivalent with Feynman path ensemble, which after Wick rotation becomes Boltzmann path ensemble - and e.g. Ising model is a basic condensed matter model, which is assumed to use Boltzmann ensemble of e.g. sequences of spins - in spatial direction instead of temporal in QM.

Such spatial realization of Wick-rotated quantum mechanics seems to allow to violate Bell-like inequalities, so a natural next question is if we could build Wick-rotated quantum computers in Ising-like systems? For example to be "printed" on a surface, solving encoded problem if assuming Boltzmann ensemble among sequences?

Notice that Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC - the latter minimizes Hamiltonian, having huge problem with usually exponentially growing number of local minima. The former is closer to Shor - exploits path ensemble, should not have this optimization problem (?)

While quantum computers use unitary gates: with eigenspectrum in complex unitary circle, such Wick-rotated gates would have real eigenspectrum.

Hadamard gate $H$ is used to get initial superposition in quantum computers, below mixing gate $X$ can be used to get (Boltzmann) ensemble in Wick-rotated computers:

$$H=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & -1 \\ \end{array} \right) \qquad\qquad X= \left(\begin{array}{cc}1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \\ \end{array} \right) $$

In theory, controlled e.g. NOT, X should be also possible, the question is what could be realized e.g. in Ising-like system?

While in quantum computers we can only fix initial amplitude in the past, a big advantage of such spatial realization is that we could fix amplitudes in both directions (left and right), what might allow e.g. to solve 3-SAT (NP-complete, end of this arxiv).

In quantum subroutine of Shor's algorithm below, we prepare ensemble (past direction) of all inputs, calculate classical function and measure its value (future direction) - restricting the initial ensemble to inputs giving the same value value of classical function, which period (found with QFT) gives a hint for the factorization problem.

Analogously for Boltzmann path ensemble for 3-SAT below, but in spatial realization we can also fix values from second direction (right) - restriction (in splits) becomes to inputs satisfying all the alternatives:

enter image description here

Which Wick-rotated gates could be realized in Ising-like systems?

Assuming we could build e.g. above 3-SAT setting, would it work? In other words - is Boltzmann sequence ensemble a perfect assumption, or only an approximation?

Is there a literature for Wick-rotated quantum computers, gates?

Wick-rotated QC is different from adiabatic QC
Source Link
Jarek Duda
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 23
Loading
Source Link
Jarek Duda
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 8
  • 23
Loading