Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

[![Concord][1]][1]Concord


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the aeroplane with yourself near the nose and your friend near the tail, both facing in the direction of the aeroplane's motion.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. [1]: https://i.sstatic.net/qJDt1.jpg

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

[![Concord][1]][1]


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the aeroplane with yourself near the nose and your friend near the tail, both facing in the direction of the aeroplane's motion.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. [1]: https://i.sstatic.net/qJDt1.jpg

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

Concord


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the aeroplane with yourself near the nose and your friend near the tail, both facing in the direction of the aeroplane's motion.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it.

deleted 221 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

Concord [![Concord][1]][1]


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the airplaneaeroplane with yourself near the nose, and your friend near the tail, both facing in the direction of the aeroplane's motion.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

Isn't it wonderful? Hearing the same message again and again without any effort from your part!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. The energy loss due to the sound propagation can be easily solved by using a hollow straight tube, between the friends. [1]: https://i.sstatic.net/qJDt1.jpg

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

Concord


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the airplane with yourself near the nose, your friend near the tail.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

Isn't it wonderful? Hearing the same message again and again without any effort from your part!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. The energy loss due to the sound propagation can be easily solved by using a hollow straight tube, between the friends.

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

[![Concord][1]][1]


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the aeroplane with yourself near the nose and your friend near the tail, both facing in the direction of the aeroplane's motion.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. [1]: https://i.sstatic.net/qJDt1.jpg

Post Closed as "Duplicate" by Kyle Kanos, AccidentalFourierTransform, Jon Custer, John Rennie, M. Enns
added 6 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

Concord


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the airplane with yourself near the nose, your friend near the tail.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reversein reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

Isn't it wonderful? Hearing the same message again and again without any effort from your part!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. The energy loss due to the sound propagation can be easily solved by using a hollow straight tube, between the friends.

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

Concord


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the airplane with yourself near the nose, your friend near the tail.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

Isn't it wonderful? Hearing the same message again and again without any effort from your part!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. The energy loss due to the sound propagation can be easily solved by using a hollow straight tube, between the friends.

I was having a discussion with a friend about supersonic flights.

Concord


It was then when he proposed an idea on an interesting experiment that can be done during a supersonic flight.

The experiment goes like this.

  • You board a supersonic jet along with your friend. The flight is cruising at Mach 1 above Amazon rainforests, or some other place with comparatively low air currents. You have somehow got the permission to do the experiment which involves getting out of the plane.

  • You both take all the safety measures and stand on both the ends of the airplane with yourself near the nose, your friend near the tail.

  • Your friend yells out something at you, but you can't hear it, because it's Mach 1.

  • You ask the pilot to slow down the plane, and the plane gradually decelerates. What happens now?

  • Your friend's sound catches up with you, and you hear the message!

  • Now, you yell out something at your friend.

  • You speed up the plane, and your friend catches up with the message.

  • Now, something remarkable happens when you do this. Your friend hears the message in reverse!!

  • Now the most interesting part:

If you keep on accelerating and decelerating the plane about the speed of sound, you can make your message to be heard multiple times by your friend!!

Isn't it wonderful? Hearing the same message again and again without any effort from your part!

It is weird, but is such an observation plausible?

UPDATE: Most of the comments posted here are about the rewinding part. In fact, that is only a part of the question. The real question emphasizes on the idea, of receiving a signal by overtaking it. The energy loss due to the sound propagation can be easily solved by using a hollow straight tube, between the friends.

removed unnecessary bold italics; deleted 6 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
deleted 113 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
Clarified content
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
Question Protected by Qmechanic
deleted 386 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Loading
edited tags
Link
Qmechanic
  • 213.1k
  • 48
  • 590
  • 2.3k
Loading
Tweeted twitter.com/StackPhysics/status/934371594796978177
deleted 4 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
Corrected spellings.
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
added 18 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
deleted 6 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
deleted 7 characters in body
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
edited title
Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
edited title
Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading
Source Link
AlphaLife
  • 12.6k
  • 6
  • 41
  • 96
Loading