Skip to main content
deleted 204 characters in body
Source Link
Emilio Pisanty
  • 135.3k
  • 33
  • 358
  • 677

To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no. Real quantum systems can and do have degenerate ground states.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest exampleexamples being boron (whose ground-state configuration is $2s^2\:2p$ with term $^2P^\mathrm{o}_{1/2}$, to which correspond two spatially different states, with $m_J=-1/2$ and $+1/2$), followed by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, and indeedwhich have $p$-shell electrons that fit multiple orthogonal magnetic-quantum-number states at exactly the same energy. The same is true for pretty much all of the periodic table except (i) the noble gases, with athe exception of atoms with full $p$ shellsubshells. Thus, (ii) the alkaline earth metals, with a full $s$ shell, (iii) zinc, cadmium, palladium and mercury, with a full $d$ shellthe noble gases, and (iv) ytterbium and nobelium, at the endrightmost columns of the transition metals and the rare earths, with a full $f$ shellhave nondegenerate ground states, and everything else is degenerate.

    (On the other hand, it is important to note that these kinds of degenerate ground states can be relatively fragile, so e.g. if the atom wanders into a stray bit of magnetic field, that will lift the degeneracy, often by a nontrivial amount. However, that doesn't mean that the free-atom ground state isn't degenerate.)

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread ─ which includes many hamiltonians of the form $-\nabla^2 +V$, regardless of the dimension, for distinguishable quantum particles. However, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.

To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no. Real quantum systems can and do have degenerate ground states.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest example being boron (whose ground-state configuration is $2s^2\:2p$ with term $^2P^\mathrm{o}_{1/2}$, to which correspond two spatially different states, with $m_J=-1/2$ and $+1/2$), followed by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, and indeed all of the periodic table except (i) the noble gases, with a full $p$ shell, (ii) the alkaline earth metals, with a full $s$ shell, (iii) zinc, cadmium, palladium and mercury, with a full $d$ shell, and (iv) ytterbium and nobelium, at the end of the rare earths, with a full $f$ shell.

    (On the other hand, it is important to note that these kinds of degenerate ground states can be relatively fragile, so e.g. if the atom wanders into a stray bit of magnetic field, that will lift the degeneracy, often by a nontrivial amount. However, that doesn't mean that the free-atom ground state isn't degenerate.)

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.

To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no. Real quantum systems can and do have degenerate ground states.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest examples being boron and carbon, which have $p$-shell electrons that fit multiple orthogonal magnetic-quantum-number states at exactly the same energy. The same is true for pretty much all of the periodic table, with the exception of atoms with full subshells. Thus, the alkaline earth metals, the noble gases, and the rightmost columns of the transition metals and the rare earths, have nondegenerate ground states, and everything else is degenerate.

    (On the other hand, it is important to note that these kinds of degenerate ground states can be relatively fragile, so e.g. if the atom wanders into a stray bit of magnetic field, that will lift the degeneracy, often by a nontrivial amount. However, that doesn't mean that the free-atom ground state isn't degenerate.)

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread ─ which includes many hamiltonians of the form $-\nabla^2 +V$, regardless of the dimension, for distinguishable quantum particles. However, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.

deleted 204 characters in body
Source Link
Emilio Pisanty
  • 135.3k
  • 33
  • 358
  • 677

The upvoted answer on this thread is pretty much a trivial tautology, and it gives the wrong impression that ground states are generically nondegenerate. To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no. Real quantum systems can and do have degenerate ground states.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest example being boron (whose ground-state configuration is $2s^2\:2p$ with term $^2P^\mathrm{o}_{1/2}$, to which correspond two spatially different states, with $m_J=-1/2$ and $+1/2$), followed by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, and indeed all of the periodic table except (i) the noble gases, with a full $p$ shell, (ii) the alkaline earth metals, with a full $s$ shell, (iii) zinc, cadmium, palladium and mercury, the group XII metals, with a full $d$ shell, and (iv) ytterbium and nobelium, at the end of the rare earths, with a full $f$ shell, and .

    (v) some exceptions such as palladiumOn the other hand, it is important to note that these kinds of degenerate ground states can be relatively fragile, so e.g. if the atom wanders into a stray bit of magnetic field, that will lift the degeneracy, often by a nontrivial amount. However, that doesn't mean that the free-atom ground state isn't degenerate.)

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.

The upvoted answer on this thread is pretty much a trivial tautology, and it gives the wrong impression that ground states are generically nondegenerate. To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest example being boron (whose ground-state configuration is $2s^2\:2p$ with term $^2P^\mathrm{o}_{1/2}$, to which correspond two spatially different states, with $m_J=-1/2$ and $+1/2$), followed by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, and indeed all of the periodic table except (i) the noble gases, with a full $p$ shell, (ii) the alkaline earth metals, with a full $s$ shell, (iii) zinc, cadmium and mercury, the group XII metals, with a full $d$ shell, (iv) ytterbium and nobelium, at the end of the rare earths, with a full $f$ shell, and (v) some exceptions such as palladium.

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.

To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no. Real quantum systems can and do have degenerate ground states.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest example being boron (whose ground-state configuration is $2s^2\:2p$ with term $^2P^\mathrm{o}_{1/2}$, to which correspond two spatially different states, with $m_J=-1/2$ and $+1/2$), followed by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, and indeed all of the periodic table except (i) the noble gases, with a full $p$ shell, (ii) the alkaline earth metals, with a full $s$ shell, (iii) zinc, cadmium, palladium and mercury, with a full $d$ shell, and (iv) ytterbium and nobelium, at the end of the rare earths, with a full $f$ shell.

    (On the other hand, it is important to note that these kinds of degenerate ground states can be relatively fragile, so e.g. if the atom wanders into a stray bit of magnetic field, that will lift the degeneracy, often by a nontrivial amount. However, that doesn't mean that the free-atom ground state isn't degenerate.)

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.

Source Link
Emilio Pisanty
  • 135.3k
  • 33
  • 358
  • 677

The upvoted answer on this thread is pretty much a trivial tautology, and it gives the wrong impression that ground states are generically nondegenerate. To be clear:

Is the ground state of a quantum system always non-degenerate?

the answer is an unequivocal no.

Some examples:

  • For a three-level system with hamiltonian $$H=\begin{pmatrix}1& 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 2\end{pmatrix},$$ as given by the OP, the ground state is degenerate. This should be all that's necessary to show that the claim is false in general.

  • Pretty much all atoms in a field-free vacuum have degenerate ground states, with the simplest example being boron (whose ground-state configuration is $2s^2\:2p$ with term $^2P^\mathrm{o}_{1/2}$, to which correspond two spatially different states, with $m_J=-1/2$ and $+1/2$), followed by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine, and indeed all of the periodic table except (i) the noble gases, with a full $p$ shell, (ii) the alkaline earth metals, with a full $s$ shell, (iii) zinc, cadmium and mercury, the group XII metals, with a full $d$ shell, (iv) ytterbium and nobelium, at the end of the rare earths, with a full $f$ shell, and (v) some exceptions such as palladium.

  • This is exactly the same situation as that pointed out in a comment, regarding atomic nuclei, whose ground state will generically have nonzero angular momentum and will therefore be spatially degenerate.

  • A slew of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic materials in lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration, which is best exhibited graphically:

    That is, if three spins are linked with pairwise anti-ferromagnetic couplings, they try to point in opposite directions to each other, but there's no global solution that will avoid high-energy parallel alignments. This then leads naturally to a degenerate ground-state manifold.

Now, there is a large class of hamiltonians for which the ground state can be shown to be nondegenerate ─ they're explored in some depth, and with good references, in this MathOverflow thread, but this class does not include all possible systems, particularly once you include fermionic particle statistics with strict antisymmetry requirements on the wavefunction.