Skip to main content
added 46 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Qmechanic
  • 213k
  • 48
  • 590
  • 2.3k

I have been doingreading the 1st chapter of Landau & Lifshitz Mechanics, and due to its concise style been facing a few problems. I hope you can help me out here somehow.

1)Does the "homogeneity of space and time" essentially talk about the invariance of the Lagrangian with co-ordinate system or time invariance? Is this the basis of Landau's proof of the Law of Inertia?

  1. The Lagrangian for a closed system of particles is described by adding a function of the co-ordinates. This essentially means that the same trajectory satisfies the extremal principle.(I am a bit confused about this though). So why the function added is not of time too?

  2. On the subject of " the Lagrangian being defined only to within an additive total time derivative of any function of co-ordinates and time", is it true that the function can be of velocity too ( Though this would make the entire exercise useless, since we would know everything)?

  1. Does the "homogeneity of space and time" essentially talk about the invariance of the Lagrangian with co-ordinate system or time invariance? Is this the basis of Landau's proof of the Law of Inertia?

  2. The Lagrangian for a closed system of particles is described by adding a function of the co-ordinates. This essentially means that the same trajectory satisfies the extremal principle. (I am a bit confused about this though). So why the function added is not of time too?

  3. On the subject of " the Lagrangian being defined only to within an additive total time derivative of any function of co-ordinates and time", is it true that the function can be of velocity too (Though this would make the entire exercise useless, since we would know everything)?

The disadvantage of trying to teach oneself physics without anyone to refer to is that I am not completely sure that what I am saying makes sense.

I have been doing Landau and due to its concise style been facing a few problems. I hope you can help me out here somehow.

1)Does the "homogeneity of space and time" essentially talk about the invariance of the Lagrangian with co-ordinate system or time invariance? Is this the basis of Landau's proof of the Law of Inertia?

  1. The Lagrangian for a closed system of particles is described by adding a function of the co-ordinates. This essentially means that the same trajectory satisfies the extremal principle.(I am a bit confused about this though). So why the function added is not of time too?

  2. On the subject of " the Lagrangian being defined only to within an additive total time derivative of any function of co-ordinates and time", is it true that the function can be of velocity too ( Though this would make the entire exercise useless, since we would know everything)?

The disadvantage of trying to teach oneself physics without anyone to refer to is that I am not completely sure that what I am saying makes sense.

I have been reading the 1st chapter of Landau & Lifshitz Mechanics, and due to its concise style been facing a few problems. I hope you can help me out here somehow.

  1. Does the "homogeneity of space and time" essentially talk about the invariance of the Lagrangian with co-ordinate system or time invariance? Is this the basis of Landau's proof of the Law of Inertia?

  2. The Lagrangian for a closed system of particles is described by adding a function of the co-ordinates. This essentially means that the same trajectory satisfies the extremal principle. (I am a bit confused about this though). So why the function added is not of time too?

  3. On the subject of " the Lagrangian being defined only to within an additive total time derivative of any function of co-ordinates and time", is it true that the function can be of velocity too (Though this would make the entire exercise useless, since we would know everything)?

The disadvantage of trying to teach oneself physics without anyone to refer to is that I am not completely sure that what I am saying makes sense.

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackPhysics/status/87587888165961728
Source Link
Sourav
  • 103
  • 1
  • 6

Invariance and forms of the Lagrangian

I have been doing Landau and due to its concise style been facing a few problems. I hope you can help me out here somehow.

1)Does the "homogeneity of space and time" essentially talk about the invariance of the Lagrangian with co-ordinate system or time invariance? Is this the basis of Landau's proof of the Law of Inertia?

  1. The Lagrangian for a closed system of particles is described by adding a function of the co-ordinates. This essentially means that the same trajectory satisfies the extremal principle.(I am a bit confused about this though). So why the function added is not of time too?

  2. On the subject of " the Lagrangian being defined only to within an additive total time derivative of any function of co-ordinates and time", is it true that the function can be of velocity too ( Though this would make the entire exercise useless, since we would know everything)?

The disadvantage of trying to teach oneself physics without anyone to refer to is that I am not completely sure that what I am saying makes sense.