Skip to main content
2 of 7
added 77 characters in body
user avatar
user avatar

##Equivalent Lagrangians

Two Lagrangians which yield the same equations of motion are called equivalent Lagrangians. It follows that Lagrangians which differ by a constant are equivalent Lagrangians (because the equations of motion derived from them turn out to be the same). In your case, $L-L_1=mv_0 ^2/2=\rm constant$, thus $L$ and $L_1$ are equivalent. For a general case, if two Lagrangians ($L$ and $L'$) are equivalent then

$$\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\left(\frac{\partial(L-L')}{\partial \dot q_i}\right)=0 \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{\mathrm d (L-L')}{\mathrm dq_i}=0 \qquad \forall \:\: i\tag{1}$$

##Derivation

Let's prove that this would be true for any inertial reference frame. Let the Lagrangian in the ground frame be

$$L=T-V=\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v_i|^2-\sum_j^m\left(\sum_i^n V_i(q_j)\right)$$

where $m_i$ and $\mathbf v_i$ are the mass and the velocity of the $i$-th particle, and $V_i$ is the potential of the $i$-th particle dependent of the coordinate $q_j$. Now let's move to a refrence frame moving with a velocity $\mathbf v$, then the new Lagrangian is

$$L'=T'-V'=\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v_i-\mathbf v|^2-\sum_j^m\left(\sum_i^n V_i(q)\right)$$

Therefore,

$$L-L'=\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v_i|^2-\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v_i-\mathbf v|^2$$

Now using the fact that $|\mathbf v_i-\mathbf v|^2=|\mathbf v_i|^2+|\mathbf v|^2-2\mathbf v_i\cdot \mathbf v$, we get

\begin{align} L-L'&=\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i (|\mathbf v_i|^2-(|\mathbf v_i|^2+|\mathbf v|^2-2\mathbf v_i\cdot \mathbf v))\\ &= \sum_i^n m_i (\mathbf v_i\cdot \mathbf v)-\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v|^2\\ &= \left(\sum_i^n m_i \mathbf v_i\right)\cdot \mathbf v-\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v|^2 \end{align}

Now we'll use the fact that $\displaystyle\sum_i^n=M\mathbf v_{\rm COM}$, where $\displaystyle M=\sum_i^n m_i$ and $\mathbf v_{\rm COM}$ is the velocity of the center of mass. Thus,

\begin{align} L-L'&=M(\mathbf v_{\rm COM}\cdot \mathbf v)-\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v|^2 \end{align}

Let the coordinate along the direction of $\mathbf v$ be $q_k$, then $\mathbf v_{\rm COM}\cdot\mathbf v=\dot{q_k}|\mathbf v|$. Substituting this, we get

\begin{align} L-L'&=M\dot{q_k}|\mathbf v|-\sum_i^n \frac 1 2 m_i |\mathbf v|^2\\ L-L'&=M\dot{q_k}|\mathbf v|-\rm constant \end{align}

Now apply the conditions in equation $(1)$, and you would find that they hold true, which implies that both the Lagrangians are equivalent. This could also be trivially proven by showing the invariance of equations of motions under changing from one inertial reference frame to another.

##Conclusion

Your instructor's statement (as you stated) is completely incorrect. However, it is correct to say that Lagrangians obtained in different inertial frames of reference are always equivalent.

user258881