Bob is in a gravitational potential well, he moves a long vertical stick up and down a distance of 1 meters. Alice observes the upper end of the stick, at upper location.

There is the phenomenon of redshift of energy, so either Alice measures a shorter motion than 1 meters, or alternatively Alice measures a weakened force.

So I'm asking: is Bob weak, or is Bob short?

( EDIT: It interests me what REALLY happens. It seems that when you fall into a black hole, you maybe become contracted: your lower part is already slowed down, while your upper part is still moving a little bit faster.

I'm certain that when you are being lowered into a gravity well, you REALLY lose energy. Therefore there REALLY is no redshift of energy when energy travels back up from a gravity well.

Now I try to make a thought experiment out of these two things: a shortened person in a gravity well, sends his reduced energy up, by poking with a stick )

EDIT 2: Question 2: Bob moves the vertical stick horizontally a 10 meters distance, what distance and what force does Alice observe at the upper end of the stick?