# Questions tagged [carnot-cycle]

The tag has no usage guidance.

177 questions
Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
0answers
2 views

### Is freezing water a carnot cycle?

Freezing water is a reversible process, but how do we know if it could be interpreted as a carnot cycle?
3answers
112 views

### Is it always true that a non-adiabatic reversible process is an isothermal process?

In a Carnot Cycle, a reversible isothermal process is a non-adiabatic reversible process. Is it always true that a non-adiabatic reversible process is an isothermal process?
0answers
24 views

### Steam flow direction through valves - Watt Engine

I don't have a background in Thermodynamics. I am trying to understand a paragraph from the book - Einstein's Fridge. The author says that when the piston is near the bottom of the cylinder, and the ...
1answer
37 views

### What is the need of adiabatic compression in Carnot cycle?

Why do we need to compress the gas adiabatically after the isothermal compression of gas? What if we just skip this step? What will be the consequences? By "skipping this step",I mean, after ...
5answers
87 views

### Why is it necessary for a heat engine to work in cycles?

We can make a steam engine just by putting huge amount of water in large tank and heat it and then use the steam to run the wheel. We just have to put huge amount of water and heat then engine will ...
3answers
41 views

### Why don't we really consider the TOTAL (SYSTEM +SURROUNDINGS) entropy change in Carnot cycle?

During a Carnot cycle, why don't we consider the increase in entropy of surrounding by the energy given to surrounding via work done by gas piston? I mean we want to find the total entropy change then ...
1answer
23 views

### Why is entropy of gas reamains constant during adiabatic expansion?

In adiabatic compression, we add energy to the gas via piston and decrease volume. Now the increase in energy and decrease in volume will cause increase and decrease in entropy respectively, but it ...
1answer
59 views

### Modified Carnot engine example requiring clarification regarding Clausius' Theorem and Second Law of Thermodynamics

If we introduce a finite temperature difference between source/drain and that of the working fluid in thermal contact, we would make the process irreversible since the direction of heat flow cannot ...
1answer
47 views

### Can we show that the “Carnot cycle is the most efficient cycle in ideal gas” without using any form of the Second Law?

My Question: Is it possible to show that the Carnot cycle is the most efficient cycle in an ideal gas without using any form of the Second Law of Thermodynamics? Also. If this is possible, how can we ...
1answer
41 views

### What's the pressure of surrounding of carnot cycle? [closed]

Is it always equal to changing pressure of cylinder? How is it possible?
2answers
50 views

### Is efficiency of Carnot engine dependent on temperature of heat source/sink?

Suppose we are working with a Carnot engine. In this engine, temperature of the heat source is say $373K$ and that of heat sink is say $293K$. Now, the initial temperature of the gas(ideal) is 333K. ...
0answers
18 views

### Volume Ratio of Carnot Engine

Consider a Carnot engine operating between a hot reservoir with temperature 700 °C and a cold reservoir with temperature 70 °C. The engine contains 0.13 mol of gas, and outputs a net 630 J of work. ...
2answers
49 views

### Change in entropy of engine and the hot bath in a cycle

I want to clarify that this question is not a homework-type question. I have provided its solution and the apparent discrepancy. This is a question from a national competitive exam I gave. I am very ...
3answers
63 views

### Reconcile different definitions of temperature

In classical thermodynamics, one way to define the temperature is to measure the efficiency of the Carnot cycle, i.e. $$w = 1-\frac{T_c}{T_h}$$ And in some other texts (like in the statistical ...
3answers
78 views

### Can heat transfer from one object to another if they both have the same temperature?

I do not understand how the heat is transferred between the reservoir and the gas in stages 1 and 3 of the Carnot Cycle (the isothermal parts of the cycle). From what I know, If two objects have the ...
2answers
54 views

### Carnot's engine

Why do we use isothermal process in Carnot's engine? I think it should be isobaric process, because when we heat the gas it goes expanding to keep the pressure constant. Why is my thinking wrong?
2answers
109 views

### What does “entropy” really mean?

I'm currently taking a course of introduction to biophysics in college and we currently covered a subject called entropy (S). We did some maths based on the Carnot cycle and came up with the following ...
1answer
52 views

### Meaning of “Heat engine working between two Temperatures”

According to Carnot Theorem: "Of all engines working between two given temperature, none is more efficient than a carnot engine." I want to know what actually is meant by an engine working ...
0answers
33 views

### Theoretical efficiency of a laser

A laser produces a coherent, collimated light beam. This is like a less-disordered version of the light from say a light bulb. When I learned about heat pumps in thermodynamics class, I found that we ...
1answer
34 views

### $p$-$V$ Diagram of a real chiller (fridge, heat pump, …)

I am struggling to find a $p$-$V$ Diagram of a real (not CARNOT!) heat pump. Regarding engines (diesel, otto) this seems to be an easy task but I am failing to do so for heat pumps. Could anyone help ...
1answer
31 views

### Carnot cycle total reversibility

I read the discussion of the same problem in another problem posted here Carnot Total Reversibility, but still I can't get the reason why Carnot cycle is stated as "Totally Reversible", it ...
1answer
53 views

### Adiabatic expansion vs. adiabatic compression in Carnot cycle

I am currently studying the Carnot cycle, and am close to understanding it, but something is nagging on my mind. So, during the expansion process of the cycle, work is done on the surroundings as heat ...
2answers
260 views

### Is Carnot cycle the only “most efficient” cycle? [duplicate]

In all the books, that I have studied so far, they say that Carnot cycle is the most efficient cycle. But why isn't any other reversible process as efficient as Carnot cycle? Can somebody please ...
2answers
129 views

### Confusion with Carnot Cycle Problem

Consider two fluids $F_1$ and $F_2$ with equal volume and heat capacity as well as $T_1$ and $T_2$ respectively, whereby $T_1 > T_2$. One uses a Carnot cycle to transfer heat from $F_1$ to $F_2$ in ...
1answer
31 views

1answer
152 views

### Proof for $\oint \frac{dQ}{T}=0$ in a reversible process

I'm actually trying to prove that Entropy is a state function. I get struck at the point where I need to prove that $\oint \frac{dQ}{T}=0$ for a reversible process. Clausius in his book The ...
2answers
1k views

### How can we show that Entropy is a State Function?

Intro: Thank you for reading. I know there are lots of questions on Stack Exchange about entropy. The following is the one that most closely addressed my confusion: Entropy as a state property ...
3answers
990 views

### Why only isothermal and adiabatic for Carnot engine?

What is the reason behind choosing adiabatic and isothermal process for carnot engine? My book states the following reason. I am not able to understand it. It would be great if you could put it in ...
1answer
154 views

### In the isothermal expansion phase of a Carnot cycle, why does the gas expand?

Descriptions of the isothermal expansion in a Carnot cycle typically say heat is absorbed by the gas and the gas expands. But why would it expand? The heat reservoir keeps the temperature constant, ...
1answer
35 views

### The reversible Carnot cycle is the most efficient between $T_2$ and $T_1$. Is it a form the second law itself?

The second law of thermodynamics proposed by Clausius, Kelvin, Carnot ..etc in its original form as T dS> dQ for irreversible process and Tds =dQ only for reversible thermodynamics process. This ...
2answers
62 views

### Apparent contradiction concerning the net work of a Carnot cycle

The net work of a Carnot cycle, $W$, is $$\tag{1}W=Q_{h}-Q_c.$$ This work also satisfies $$\tag{2}W=Q_{h}\bigg ( 1-\frac{T_c}{T_h} \bigg )$$ Let us fix $Q_{h}$, the amount of heat initially ...
2answers
37 views

### Deriving $Q_{1}-Q_{2}=W$ for a perfect gas that had gone through a Carnot cycle

I saw multiple times that if an engine, say Carnot engine, absorbs heat $Q_{1}$ at $T_{1}$, does work $W$, and expels heat $Q_{2}$ at $T_{2}$, then we should have$$\tag{1}Q_{1}-Q_{2}=W.$$ Let us say ...
0answers
92 views

### How do I use calculus of variations to prove that Carnot cycle is the most efficient one?

There are already many questions on Physics SE asking for a proof of the maximum possible efficiency of Carnot's engine. However, none of them (at least the ones which I looked up) contain a ...
2answers
57 views

### Why does the gas compress during isothermal compression, in the carnot cycle

In this step, the gas is said to release some heat dq. From where does energy come from? The temperatures are the same, so internal energy won't flow. But the gas compresses, hence the change in ...
2answers
49 views

### About the adiabatic stroke in the Carnot cycle

I understood that in the adiabatic stroke, the internal energy is being used up to do work Again, assuming that the internal energy of all the gas molecules of the system are the same (can we?) Why ...
1answer
163 views

### Can anyone prove this overstated-but-almost-never-justified fact from thermodynamics?

Clausius inequality states that $\oint {\delta Q\over T}$ equals zero for a system undergoing a reversible cycle, whereas it can’t be greater than zero for an irreversible cycle. But everywhere, I ...
1answer
78 views

### Efficiency of heat engines

I have been taught that the an engine running on the Carnot's cycle has the maximum energy among the maximum efficiency, however I never found a convincing proof for it. Wherever I have put this ...
1answer
84 views

### Efficiency of sequential Carnot engines [closed]

A Carnot engine A operates between temperature $T_1$ and $T_2$ ($T_1>T_2$). A second Carnot engine B uses all the heat rejected by A as input and input and operates between temperature $T_2$ and \$...
0answers
46 views

### Why an ideal gas expands in the 2nd step of carnot's cycle/engine?

In the 2nd step of carnot's cycle, when the gas cylinder is kept under an adiabatic condition, it expands and the temperature falls. My question is why does the gas spend it's internal energy to ...
1answer
197 views

### Efficiency of a reversible thermodinamic cycle

1 mole of ideal monoatomic gas completes a reversible ABC cycle, in which AB is a VOlume constant tranformation, BC an adiabatic expansion(Q=0) and CA an isotherm(Temperature during tranformation is ...
2answers
268 views

### Efficiency of Carnot engine [duplicate]

Why is the efficiency of Carnot engine regarded as the maximum efficiency possible for a heat engine?
1answer
229 views

### How does the Carnot Cycle work?

I am learning the Carnot cycle, which consists of four transformations for a fluid. In the first two transformations the volume of the fluid expands, generating work. This happens in two steps: ...