35 questions linked to/from Is the world $C^\infty$?
809 views

Classical Mechanics: Continuous or Discrete universe? [duplicate]

The question of the "continuous" or "discrete" nature of the universe is the subject of diatribe among the greatest physicists in the world. I would like to discuss the same topic, but asking a ...
1 vote
26 views

How "smooth" is the evolution of the universe? [duplicate]

Mathematicians have developed different definitions for how "smooth" a function might be. A function (e.g. from or to $\mathbb{R}^n$ or $\mathbb{C}^n$) might be continuous, or once-...
• 225
19 views

Infinite differentiablity in Nature? [duplicate]

I'm working through understanding Clay Institute's paper addressing their Navier-Stokes millennium prize. I can't find any resources online stating if there are any infinitely differentiable examples ...
7k views

Why don't we prove that functions used in physics are continuous and differentiable?

I have studied physics up to 12th grade and I noticed that whenever new equations are introduced for certain entities, such as a simple harmonic wave, we never prove that it's continuous everywhere or ...
10k views

Why does Taylor’s series “work”?

I am an undergraduate Physics student completing my first year shortly. The following question is based on the physical systems I’ve encountered so far. (We mostly did Newtonian mechanics.) In all of ...
• 1,783
841 views

In GR, why should the spacetime manifold be differentiable?

In general relativity (GR), spacetime is viewed as a differentiable manifold of dimension $D$ with a metric of Lorentzian signature $(-,+,+,...,+)$. My question is why differentiable?
• 1,246
921 views

Why is analyticity a good mathematical assumption in general relativity?

In general relativity, real-variable analytic continuation is commonly used to understand spacetimes. For example, we use it to extend the Schwarzschild spacetime to the Kruskal spacetime, and also ...
• 95.4k
2k views

Is it guaranteed that wavefunction is well behaved everywhere?

I don't really know much about Quantum mechanics, but would like to know one simple fact. The state function $\Psi(r, t)$ whose magnitude gives the probability density of the position of the particle ...
• 2,102
7k views

Use of the mathematical concept 'function' in theoretical physics

The mathematical concept of function is used in physics to represent different physical quantities. For example the air pressure variation with time and space is called an acoustic wave. We use a ...
• 2,102
2k views

Are velocity and acceleration smooth quantities?

My thinking: acceleration corresponds to a force which is instantaneous, so the acceleration of a rigid body can be rather spiky (non-smooth) velocity (angular velocity) describes the ratio of ...
• 123
706 views

Why do we consider potential energy function $U(x)$ differentiable?

Recently when skimming through my physics-text I encountered an interesting definition of Force $$F(x) = -\frac{\mathrm dU(x)}{\mathrm dx}$$ We were taught that some functions are continuous but not ...
• 373
543 views

Is it normal for physical functions to lack a 2nd derivative?

My question is about the appearance of a non-analytic function in the formula for the resistive force in air or other medium. Considering the 1-dimensional case as covered by Walter Lewin in his 8.01 ...
1 vote
312 views

Can motion graphs have sharp edges?

I'm pretty convinced but I need to make sure I'm right about this. By a sharp edge, I mean a point in the graph where the curve is not differentiable. in motion graphs, (x,y,z) coordinates depend on ...
398 views

Why do we assume simply connected domains and continuously differentiable fields in electromagnetism theory?

In many textbooks, including Griffiths', they erroneously claim that a field is irrotational if and only if it is conservative (there exists a scalar potential). This is true only if the domain of ...
• 225
In electromagnetism, we say that any conservative electric field $\vec{E}(\vec{r})$ is associated to a scalar potential $V(\vec{r})$ such that $\vec{E}(\vec{r}) = -\nabla V(\vec{r})$. If the electric ...