$\def\mybra#1{\langle{#1}|}$ $\def\myket#1{|{#1}\rangle}$ $\def\Tr{\mbox{Tr}}$ $\def\mybraket#1{\langle{#1}\rangle}$ $\def\B#1#2{B^{#1}_{#2}}$



I want to expand my density operator $$ \hat \rho = \sum_{jm j'm'} \myket{jm}\mybraket{jm|\hat \rho|j'm'} \mybra{j'm'}\tag1 $$ with spherical tensor operators, $$ \hat\rho = \sum_{k}\sum_{q=-k}^k c^k_q\r kq,\tag2 $$ where $\myket{jm}$ is eigen vector of angular momentum $\hat J_z$, and $$ \hat\rho^k_q = \sum_{jmj'm'} \B{jm}{kq j'm'} \myket{jm}\mybra{j'm'}\tag3 $$ is spherical operator that satisfies $$ [\hat J_z,\r kq]=q\hbar \hat\rho^kq,\quad [\hat J_\pm ,\hat\rho^kq] = \hbar\sqrt{k(k+1)-q(q\pm 1)}\r k{q\pm1}. \tag4 $$ Using recursion relations of C-G coefficients, $\B{jm}{kqj'm'}$ can be determined to be C-G coefficient except a scale factor, $$ \B{jm}{kqj'm'}=f_{{kjj'}} \C{jm}{kqj'm'},\quad \C{jm}{kqj'm'} = \mybraket{kqj'm'|(kj')jm}.\tag5 $$ The factor should be independent of $m,m'$ because the recursion relation changes $m,m',q$.

To determine $f_{kjj'}$ and $c^k_q$, I should make use of the orthogonality and completeness. For orthogonality, $$ \Tr((\r {k_1}{q_1})^\dagger \r {k_2}{q_2}) = \sum f_{k_1j_1j_1'}^* f_{k_2j_2j_2'} \C{j_1m_1}{k_1q_1 j_1'm_1'}\C{j_2m_2}{k_2q_2 j_2'm_2'} \delta_{jj_1'}\delta_{mm_1'}\delta_{jj_2'}\delta_{j_1j_2}\delta_{m_1m_2} \delta_{mm_2'}.\tag6 $$ With the restriction $m_1=m_1'+q_1, m_2=m_2'+q_2$, the delta's in the sum indicates the L.H.S equals 0 unless $q_1=q_2$. And only three summation variables $j_1,j,m$ are left, $$ \Tr((\r {k_1}{q_1})^\dagger \r {k_2}{q_2}) =\sum_{j_1,j,m} f_{k_1j_1j}^* f_{k_2j_1j} \C{j_1(m+q_1)}{k_1q_1 jm}\C{j_1(m+q_1)}{k_2q_1 jm}.\tag7 $$ Using symmetry property of C-G coefficients $$ \C{jm}{j_1m_1 j_2m_2}=\sqrt{\frac{2j+1}{2j_2+1}} (-)^{j_1-m_1} \C{j_2(-m_2)}{j_1m_1j(-m)},\tag8 $$ I get $$ \begin{aligned} \Tr((\r {k_1}{q_1})^\dagger \r {k_2}{q_2}) &= \sum_{j_1,j,m} f_{k_1j_1j}^* f_{k_2j_1j} \C{j_1(m+q_1)}{k_1q_1 jm}\C{j_1(m+q_1)}{k_2q_1 jm} \\ &= \sum_{j_1,j,m} f_{k_1j_1j}^* f_{k_2j_1j}{\frac{2j_1+1 }{2j+1}} \C{j(-m)}{k_1q_1 j_1(-m-q_1)}\C{j(-m)}{k_2q_1 j_1(-m-q_1)}\\ &= \sum_{j_1,j,m} f_{k_1j_1j}^* f_{k_2j_1j}{\frac{2j_1+1 }{2j+1}} \C{jm}{k_1q_1 j_1(m+q_1)}\C{jm}{k_2q_1 j_1(m+q_1)}. \end{aligned}\tag9 $$ The third equaliy holds because summation over $m$ is symmetric about 0. Let $f_{kj'j}=f_k\sqrt{(2j+1)/(2j'+1)}$ where $f_k$ is another factor to be determined, so $$ \Tr((\r {k_1}{q_1})^\dagger \r {k_2}{q_2}) = f_{k_1}^* f_{k_2} \sum_{j_1jm} \C{jm}{k_1q_1 j_1(m+q_1)}\C{jm}{k_2q_1 j_1(m+q_1)}. \tag{10} $$

Now, if $k_1=k_2$ I can tell the summation is $1$ using the orthonality of C-G coefficients. But I can't tell if it's 0 when $k_1\neq k_2$. What's the next step?


1 Answer 1


Actually this is baked into your sum over $j$. Write $m_1=m+q_1$ and use $$ \sum_{jm} C^{jm}_{k_1q_1,j_1m_1}C^{jm}_{k_1q_1,j_1m_1}=\delta_{k_1k_2} $$ To see this, write your CG as an overlap: $$ C^{jm}_{k_1q_1,j_1m_1}=\langle jm \vert k_1q_1,j_1m_1\rangle=\langle k_1q_1,j_1m_1\vert jm\rangle $$ since CG's are real. Then $$ \sum_{jm} C^{jm}_{k_1q_1,j_1m_1}C^{jm}_{k_2q_1,j_1m_1}= \sum _{jm}\langle k_1q_1,j_1m_1\vert jm\rangle\langle jm \vert k_2q_1,j_1m_1\rangle\\ =\langle k_1q_1,j_1m_1\vert\left[\sum_{jm}\vert jm\rangle\langle jm \vert \right]\vert k_2q_1,j_1m_1\rangle $$ and the term in bracket is just the expansion of unity so you're left with $$ \sum_{jm} C^{jm}_{k_1q_1,j_1m_1}C^{jm}_{k_1q_1,j_1m_1}= \langle k_1q_1,j_1m_1\vert k_2q_1,j_1m_1\rangle=\delta_{k_1k_2}\, . $$

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you, but it confuses me whether I can exchange the sum and dirac noations when $m_1=m+q$, which is dependent of $m$. $\endgroup$
    – Luessiaw
    Commented Oct 19, 2023 at 23:00
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @Luessiaw the CGs are 0 unless $m_1=m+q$ so you can always insert $m_1$ as an independent index: when $m_1=m+q$ the CG is the one you want and when $m_1\ne m+q$ you are adding $0$ to the sum. $\endgroup$ Commented Oct 19, 2023 at 23:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.