I'm trying to understand the Dirac notation to understand quantum mechanics better. I'm trying to show the above relation using the Dirac notation.


$$\mathrm{Tr}(X)~=~\sum_j\langle j|X|j\rangle$$ and $$\mathrm{Tr}(Y)~=~\sum_j\langle j|Y|j\rangle.$$ Thus,$$\mathrm{Tr}(XY)~=~\sum_{ij}\langle j|X|i\rangle \langle i|Y|j\rangle.$$ And isn't that just equal to the following $$\mathrm{Tr}(XY)~=~\sum_j \langle j|XY|j\rangle?$$ But that shouldn't equal the following $$\mathrm{Tr}(XY)~=~\sum_j\langle j|YX|j\rangle,$$ since $XY \neq YX$, right?


3 Answers 3


Remember that $\Sigma_i |i \rangle \langle i |$ is the identity operator.

Then $Tr(XY) = \Sigma_j \langle j| XY |j \rangle = \Sigma_j \langle j| X \left(\Sigma_i |i \rangle \langle i |\right)Y |j \rangle = \Sigma_j \Sigma_i \langle j| X |i \rangle \langle i |Y |j \rangle =\Sigma_j \Sigma_i \langle i |Y |j \rangle \langle j| X |i \rangle = \Sigma_i \Sigma_j \langle i |Y |j \rangle \langle j| X |i \rangle = \Sigma_i \langle i |Y \left( \Sigma_j |j \rangle \langle j | \right) X |i \rangle =\Sigma_i \langle i |Y X |i \rangle = Tr(YX)$.

So the two traces are equal.


Throwing a wrench in the works, we mention that

$${\rm Tr}[X,Y]~=~0$$

does not always hold for two linear operators $$X:D(X)\subseteq H~\to~ H\qquad\text{and}\qquad Y:D(Y)\subseteq H~\to~ H$$ in an infinite-dimensional vector space $H$. This is not just an academic remark. Take for instance the trace on both sides of the canonical commutation relations

$$ [\hat{x},\hat{p}]~=~i\hbar{\bf 1}, $$

cf. Example 1 in Ref. 1 and this Phys.SE post.


  1. F. Gieres, Mathematical surprises and Dirac’s formalism in quantum mechanics, arXiv:quant-ph/9907069. (Hat tip: David Bar Moshe.)

To extend @NowIGetToLearnWhatAHe's answer, it should be noted that it's a general theorem of linear algebra that traces are cyclical, so it's always true that:

$$Tr(ABCDE...XYZ) = Tr(ZABCDE...XY)$$

From this, your result follows as a special case.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.