The Unruh effect was predicted in 1976.

As someone with no background in experimental physics I find it surprising this effect hasn't been measured yet. What are the experimental difficulties (and serious proposals) in measuring this effect?


2 Answers 2


Detected Hawking–Unruh thermal bath temperature and acceleration needed for a detector to achieve registration of that vacuum temperature near detector surroundings and Unruh radiation, if any, is related by

$$a={\frac {2\pi ck_{\mathrm {B} }}{\hbar }}~T \tag 1 $$

So from (1) follows that if you want to register just $10^{−10}K$ minuscule thermal bath, you need to move at amazing $10^{10}~m/s^2$ (or in terms of $g$ $\approx 10^9~\text{g}$) acceleration. So basic problems follows :

  • How to achieve these high accelerations. Supposedly first time Unruh effect was detected in CERN particle acceleration NA63 experiment by 2019.
  • How to isolate other heat sources, for being sure that we detect Unruh thermal bath, especially when (like in my given example) this expected temperature is very low.
  • Interpretation problems. While Unruh vacuum heating (thermal bath) is pretty much accepted by scientific community,- Unruh radiation does not. Like these authors which tries to prove that actually

the detector moving under a constant force and coupled to a one-dimensional scalar field [...] does not radiate

Even if it does,- this radiation should be minuscule and hence hardly distinguishable from other sources, like black body radiation of a moving detector itself (unless you move in $g$ comparable to the surface gravity of a typical black hole).

So, the conclusion is that, unless detector can simulate accelerations concieved by back hole,- no clean success of repeatable experiments are possible at "weak" conditions.


The conditions to measure the Unruh effect/ Unruh radiation are very difficult to produce with our current experimental capabilities. We need a relativistic accelerating frame to produce this radiation, creating very high acceleration and sustaining the acceleration for a long time is beyond our current experimental capability. Right now, there are already works done on quantum simulators to measure the Unruh effect, which may be of interest to you

[1] Quantum simulation of Unruh radiation, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-019-0537-1

[2] Quantum Simulation of Coherent Hawking-Unruh Radiation, https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.07504

[3] A quantum simulation of Unruh radiation, https://phys.org/news/2019-06-quantum-simulation-unruh.html


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.