0
$\begingroup$

I am reading the article named Manipulating Atoms with Photons by Claude Cohen-Tannoudji and Jean Dalibard. On page no. 16, the following is said.

Consider the atom in its ground state $g$ and its center of mass initially at rest; suppose that a photon with wave vector $\textbf{k}$ is sent on this atom. If the atom absorbs the photon, it jumps to the excited state and it recoils with the momentum $\hbar\textbf{k}$.

My confusion

I am confused about the direction of the recoil momentum.

To be specific, let's say the photon's wave vector is $\textbf{k} = k\hat{x}$, where $\hat{x}$ is the unit vector. If the atom absorbs the corresponding momentum $\textbf{p}_\text{photon} \equiv \hbar\textbf{k} = \hbar k \hat{x}$, then I think the recoil momentum is $\textbf{p}_\text{recoil} = -\hbar\textbf{k} = -\hbar k \hat{x}$, so that the momentum of the atom is conserved before (it is $0$) and after the absorption ($\textbf{p}_\text{photon} + \textbf{p}_\text{recoil} = 0$). What am I missing here?

$\endgroup$
1
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ > "then I think the recoil momentum is ... $-\hbar\mathbf k$" That makes no sense. The photon is absorbed, so its momentum lives on as momentum of the atom. There is always momentum $\hbar \mathbf k$. No body here has momentum $-\hbar\mathbf k$. $\endgroup$ Jan 10 at 21:46

1 Answer 1

2
$\begingroup$

I am reading the article named [Manipulating Atoms with Photons][1] by Claude Cohen-Tannoudji and Jean Dalibard. On page no. 16, the following is said.

Consider the atom in its ground state $g$ and its center of mass initially at rest; suppose that a photon with wave vector $\textbf{k}$ is sent on this atom. If the atom absorbs the photon, it jumps to the excited state and it recoils with the momentum $\hbar\textbf{k}$.

I am confused about the direction of the recoil momentum. To be specific, let's say the photon's wave vector is $\textbf{k} = k\hat{x}$, where $\hat{x}$ is the unit vector. If the atom absorbs the corresponding momentum $\textbf{p}_\text{photon} \equiv \hbar\textbf{k} = \hbar k \hat{x}$,

...then I think the recoil momentum is $\textbf{p}_\text{recoil} = -\hbar\textbf{k} = -\hbar k \hat{x}$

No, that is wrong. You should have: $$ \textbf{p}_\text{recoil} = \textbf{p}_\text{photon}=\hbar\textbf{k} $$

The total initial momentum is: $$ 0\;+\; \hbar\textbf{k}\;, $$ where $0$ is the initial momentum of the atom and $\hbar\textbf{k}$ is the initial momentum of the photon.

The total final momentum is: $$ \hbar\textbf{k}\;+\; 0\;, $$ where $\hbar\textbf{k}$ is the final momentum of the atom and $0$ is the final momentum of the photon.

What am I missing here?

Conservation of momentum applies to the total/isolated system of atom plus photon: $$ \textbf{P}_\text{total} = \textbf{p}_\text{atom} + \textbf{p}_\text{photon} $$

It is only $\textbf{P}_\text{total}$ that is necessarily conserved. Since $\textbf{P}_\text{total}$ started off as $\hbar\textbf{k}$ it must alway remain at that value regardless of how you apportion it between atom and photon.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.