A scammer got a hollow gold bar and fills it with a combination of lead and air, with the same average density as gold.

What's the simplest way of discovering the fraud? I know that x-rays will see it, but are there simple means for analyzing it? (without destroying it)


Send an ultrasonic pulse through the gold bar and analyse the returning wave. This technique is actually used to detect impurities in gold bars.

To quote this article:

Where the wave encounters a region of material with different physical properties – particularly the density and elastic constants – to the rest of the metal, the beam is affected in a number of ways:

Scattering (attenuation) can occur as a portion of the wave is reflected or reradiated from small regions of different material, or from an irregular interface between two larger regions of different material. This manifests itself as a reduction in the amplitude of the wave

A change of arrival time of the wave at the detecting transducer can occur if the wave passes through a significant region of material where the ultrasonic velocity is different

Refraction/reflection of the wave – or where there is a relatively (compared with the wavelengths of ultrasound used) smooth interface between two regions of different material, a portion of the wave will be reflected from this interface. Impurities will result in the wave being refracted at a different angle


Edit: I realize now that measuring the difference in resistance is not practically easy as the resistivity difference isn't significant, and there are numerous other measurement challenges including surface areas for contacts creating a significant enough difference for this method to work. Other methods may be more suitable.

If it's a cuboid, then I think a simpler way would be to measure its resistance.

  1. Use Suitable contacts
  2. Measure resistance
  3. Use R=ρL/A and find out resistivity ρ.
  4. Either use the table found here and check if it matches up

You can also use similar method for other properties like

-Thermal conductivity: Heat one end and monitor how quickly the other end's temperature rises, etc and compare to expected value or just another gold bar of similar dimension(which shouldn't be too difficult)

-Ultrasonic pulse (like'Pulsar' mentioned)

-A similar technique can be used with other rf wave reflection analysis. The pattern reflected would differ from a solid gold bar.

-Another method that comes to mind is Electrodynamic suspension. You can suspend it in air, but the eddy current will be different because it is hollow, and thus the induced magnetic field strength will be different. For a given time-varying magnetic field function, the response would differ.

But I personally think that the resistance measurement is the easiest.

All these are non destructive, btw. (Not so much for the scammer.)


This answer will not make me popular because it gets people up to speed fast on protecting themselves from thieves and levels the playing field for people who like to maintain their advantage over others.

There are a few methods we use to determine if gold is bunk or real...Methods that test if your gold is hollow, filled, alloyed (and the alloy percentages and what the alloy material might be) and if it is plated bait material for duping people unaware of practical testing methods (Tungsten has been known to bait gold bars (historically)).

  1. You can cut the bar in half...You will then know immediately of you got bunk gold.

  2. You can do a specific gravity check of your gold. There are scales designed for this purpose and use weight by displacing water. You have heard that gold is roughly 19 times as heavy as water.

  3. Next you can do a spectral analysis using XRF Spectroscopy. This is a newer method for testing requiring you to drill a small core sample and zap it using a handheld gun or placing it in a table top unit. This is very accurate.

  4. You can do scratch tests which are old-school comparisons using a a ring of gold and silver karat keys and acid to do this side-by-side comparison.

  5. Another method is acid digestion/precipitation using aqua regia super acid (Nitric/Hydrochloric acid mixture). This is a more common method and this fundamental method is part of a foundation called qualitative/quantitative measurement and was taught to high school kids in the 40's and 50's. To precipitate you would use a mixture of some sodium and sulfur combination or by controlling the PH levels via heat and sodium hydroxide gold drops out of solution when you raise the PH level between 9 and 10. If you go higher on the scale you start to drop other unwanted metals. This is usually done with smaller amounts of gold

  6. If you don't trust yourself you can send a sample of your material to ALS Global. This is the one of several Canadian companies that are trusted for materials analysis (based on a USGS study I found 5 years back). The turn around time on analysis is usually 2-3 days. You don't get your samples back, and time can drag depending on the quantity of materials you are testing. They have packages to select from and they are reasonably priced (if you are not in the know on testing or just rather have the experts deal with it then use ALS). I have also done this with very small samples.

In the gold and silver markets there are all types of things you have to be careful about. The best method is to vet your sources.

  • $\begingroup$ 1. very expensive - you will lose a lot of material in the blade kerf. May as well melt it instead. $\endgroup$ – paul Aug 13 '14 at 0:33
  • $\begingroup$ 2. The whole point of tungsten cores is to fake out this kind of test. $\endgroup$ – paul Aug 13 '14 at 0:35
  • $\begingroup$ 3. Also quite expensive in source material. $\endgroup$ – paul Aug 13 '14 at 0:36
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ 4-6. Unless you drill right through the bar you will only test the pure-gold surface layer. However, if you have a tungsten core the drill bit will stop there (and likely break) $\endgroup$ – paul Aug 13 '14 at 0:39
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @paul You would need an incredible furnace to melt tungsten :) it is amazingly high. Gold is much less (you probably know this). Cutting it would indeed be ridiculous (a diamond dremal would do it and a burr for shaping would also be needed to get it to the useful shape). To point 3. Tungsten is cheap but the activity of cutting shaping and baiting gold would be a huge hassle. I can understand why people would do it. To take a good sample you would have to drill through it but Tungsten would wreck a drill you are right on that point as well. All very good points. You must have some experience. $\endgroup$ – Frank Tudor Aug 13 '14 at 16:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.