0
$\begingroup$

So, I have doubts regarding the work done on the gas in this situation:

Let's say I have an ideal gas inside an adiabatic cylinder fitted with a piston of area $A$.
The piston has mass $M$.
Outside the cylinder there's atmospheric pressure $p_{atm}$.
Suppose the gas and the piston are at equilibrium and the piston is at a distance $h$ from the bottom of the cylinder. Then, a mass $m$ is put on the piston, which compresses the gas until equilibrium is reached again.

In calculating the work done on the gas by the enviroment, which is: $$ W =\int p \,dV $$ I would assume that I should use the external pressure that can be written as: $$p_{ext} = p_{atm} + \frac{mg}{A} + \frac{Mg}{A}$$
Therefore, the work becomes: $$W = \big(p_{atm} + \frac{mg}{A} + \frac{Mg}{A}\big) \Delta V$$ Is this right? The fact that there's a contribution to the work given by atmospheric pressure and the weight of the piston bugs me a little, because before the mass $m$ was put on the cylinder, everything was at rest. To me, it doesn't feel right that something other than the mass $m$ is doing work on the cylinder.
Should I replace the pressure in the work integral with just the pressure given by the mass $m$, instead? Because that's the difference in pressure that breaks the equilibrium? In that case the work would become: $$ W_? = \frac{mg}{A} \Delta V$$ Now, if I call the linear displacement of the piston $x$. The final volume of the gas would be $V_1 = (h - x) A$.
Since the initial volume is $ V_0 = h A$, $\Delta V$ becomes:$$\Delta V = V_1 - V_0 = - A x$$ Therefore the work, following this reasoning, would be:$$ W_? =\frac{mg}{A} (-Ax) = -mgx$$ To me, this makes more sense because it means that the work done on the gas is equal to the potential energy that the mass $m$ loses going from $h$ to $h-x$.
Could you explain to me which is correct, $W$ or $W_?$ and why?
Thanks for taking the time

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

0
$\begingroup$

The first version is correct. The atmospheric pressure is accompanied by a volume change in going from the initial state to the final state, and the potential energy of both masses change when they do work on the gas.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.