0
$\begingroup$

The General Uncertainty Principle of 2 Operators is given by

$$(\Delta X)^2\,(\Delta Y)^2 \geq\left(\dfrac{1}{2}\big\langle\{X,Y\}\big\rangle - \big\langle X\big\rangle \big\langle Y\big\rangle\right)^2+\left(\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[X,Y]\big\rangle\right)^2$$

Now I witnessed a lot of people asking why omitting the anti-commutator that is to say:

$$(\Delta X)^2\,(\Delta Y)^2 \geq \left|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[X,Y]\big\rangle\right|$$

It oftentimes had been argued the other vanishing terms really have no other meaning, but what about calculating it explicitly e.g. for $X = \hat{x},\quad Y = \hat{p}?$ There I receive in position space:

$$(\Delta \hat{x})^2\,(\Delta \hat{y})^2 \geq \left(\dfrac{1}{2}\Big\langle \dfrac{2}{\hbar\,i}\,x\,\partial_x+\dfrac{\hbar}{i}\Big\rangle-\big\langle x\big\rangle\big\langle \hbar/i\,\partial_x\rangle\right)^2 - \dfrac{1}{4}\left(\Big\langle\dfrac{h}{i}\Big\rangle\right)^2$$

$\underline{\text{I really do not see how this expression is supposed to be larger than the minimal Heisenberg estimate:}}$

$$(\Delta X)^2\,(\Delta Y)^2 \geq \left|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[X,Y]\big\rangle\right| = \dfrac{\hbar}{2}$$

Also what does it mean having unmatched derivative $(\partial_x)$ in the unpleasant large formula?

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

2
$\begingroup$

The correct generalized uncertainty relation is

$$(\Delta X)^2\,(\Delta Y)^2 \geq\left|\dfrac{1}{2}\big\langle\{\hat X,\hat Y\}\big\rangle - \big\langle \hat X\big\rangle \big\langle \hat Y\big\rangle\right|^2+\left|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[\hat X,\hat Y]\big\rangle\right|^2.$$

Note the absolute values: both terms are non-negative. The weaker uncertainty relation follows immediately from the fact that the first term is non-negative:

$$(\Delta X)^2\,(\Delta Y)^2 \geq\left|\dfrac{1}{2}\big\langle\{\hat X,\hat Y\}\big\rangle - \big\langle \hat X\big\rangle \big\langle \hat Y\big\rangle\right|^2+\left|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[\hat X,\hat Y]\big\rangle\right|^2 \geq \left|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[\hat X,\hat Y]\big\rangle\right|^2.$$

$\endgroup$
3
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ yes the absolute value is essential… $\endgroup$ Commented Jun 2, 2022 at 22:04
  • $\begingroup$ Alright I am left with another confusion: why in Heisenberg uncertainty $$|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\langle[x,p]\rangle|^2 > |\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\langle[x,p]\rangle|$$ while $$\dfrac{\hbar^2}{4}<\dfrac{\hbar}{2}$$ ? $\endgroup$
    – Leon
    Commented Jun 4, 2022 at 22:18
  • $\begingroup$ @Leon You have an error in your question. The Heisenberg uncertainty relation is $$\Delta X\Delta Y \geq \left|\dfrac{1}{2\,i}\big\langle[\hat X,\hat Y]\big\rangle\right|.$$ No squares on the left hand side. It also makes no sense to compare $\hbar^2/4$ and $\hbar/2$: they have different dimensions. $\endgroup$
    – Puk
    Commented Jun 5, 2022 at 0:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.