Is there a physical reason why annihilation of 2 identical fermions with mass m to 2 scalars amplitude for $s=4m^2$ (fermions at rest) is zero? For example we can have 2 scalars annihilating in 2 scalars and the amplitude is non-zero if we have a quadrilinear term in the largangian $\phi_1^2 \phi_2^2$. Also a decay of a scalar to 2 fermions at $s=4m^2$ (m - fermion mass) is zero.

I consider a Yukawa lagrangian $Y\bar{\psi}\psi\phi$, an annihilation in t and u channels at the tree level. I actually am interested in amplitude modulus squared and take an average over all spin states.

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ If you reverse the process, that is 2 scalars => 2 fermions, the minimum energy for this process is 2 times the mass of a fermion, so it is not surprising to have a zero amplitude for $s = 4m^2$ $\endgroup$ – Trimok Jun 5 '13 at 9:46

For generally valid reasons, the amplitudes analytically depend on the momenta and on $s$ in particular. There can't be any "jumps", the simplest discontinuities. Because the processes you enumerated with the total energy $E_{cm}\lt 2m$ i.e. $s\lt 4m^2$ are strictly prohibited by energy conservation – $2m$ is the minimum energy two fermions may have, as Trimok said – and because of the continuity, the amplitude has to be zero not only for $s\lt 4m^2$ but also for the borderline case $s=4m^2$.

The argument in the previous paragraph was sloppy and neglected the fact that the prohibition of the processes may come from $M=0$ or from the kinematic factors and that's why the cases of bosons and fermions are different. The amplitudes near the threshold of production – in our case, $s=4m^2$ – are increasing as a higher power law i.e. they are more suppressed for the fermions than for the bosons. This ultimately boils down to the normalization of the scalar-like or spinor-like solutions of the free equations of motion.

To fully understand how it works, just do the careful calculation of your simple two cases and carefully watch the powers of $(E_{fermion}-m)$ that appear in the kinematic factors and the dynamic amplitudes both in the bosonic and fermionic case.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.