FORNOTE: Hey all :) this is my first time posting and I apologise if I have written a block I wanted to be as precise with my question and reasoning as possible, also the question is summarised in the first paragraph while the rest is me explaining what I have thought about doing (stack exchange told me to do so). I hope one of yous has an answer and I look forward to reading it.

My question can be summarised as follows, where I will describe context later. Lets say we have two hollow spheres, one with radius r and another with radius $r+\alpha$, for $\alpha$ positive, and the smaller hollow sphere is inside the larger one like a nesting doll. The volume between these sphere's has a pressure and the value of this pressure is important for my purposes. The sphere's are also sufficiently elastic and I would like to know what physical law (and hopefully equation) would govern the pressure change within the volume between the two spheres if the outer sphere were to be stretched. i.e The volume between the spheres increases. I know that, in the long run, what will happen is that the smaller sphere will expand itself but this is only due to a pressure gradient and therefore negative (relative) pressure must have been created in the first place. This is important to the context as the model will implement change in the system incrementally and the pressure gradient will have to be large enough to overcome resistive elastic forces of the membranes. NOTE: whenever I say sphere I mean hollow sphere.

I have thought about using the ideal gas equation but unfortunately, in the full context of the system I am trying to model, the volume between the 'spheres' is actually a mixture of gas and liquid, not to mention that the gas equation is less than ideal for most purposes. The latest idea I have had is using the Laplace law for spherical membranes but I am not too familiar with it as I have learn what I know through reading articles online. Is it modifiable to work with non spherical structures, if so how?

And most ambitiously would such an approach work and be scientifically sound: From the laplace eq. for spherical volumes: $P_i - P_o = 2 \gamma /r$ where $\gamma$ is the surface tension of the membrane. I can call the pressure inside the small sphere $P^{1}_i$ and the pressure enclosed between the two spheres $P^{2}_i$. If I know the radius of the larger sphere has expanded to an amount then from the equation (using $p_o = atmospheric pressure$) I can see what the pressure inside the system should be, subtract it from $p^{1}_i$ & $p^{2}_i$ to find the pressure difference.

Thanks all.

  • $\begingroup$ Can you supply a schematics, your problem diagram ? Physics is about diagrams & formulas. And if you can paint a one - you have solved a half problem. $\endgroup$ Apr 22, 2021 at 19:24

1 Answer 1


The Second Law tells us that at equilibrium, the relevant energy potential will be minimized. Consider, for example, the case of a hollow sphere containing another hollow sphere, with an ideal gas filling the inner sphere and the space between the spheres:

enter image description here

I believe this is a simplified version of the arrangement you describe. At constant temperature, the energy of the ideal gas remains unchanged, and if the size of the outer sphere is controlled, then mechanical equilibrium rests on minimization of the strain energy within the inner sphere plus the pressure–volume work associated with the gas on either side of the inner sphere.

Put another way, the sphere will expand or contract if the strain energy penalty is less than the work done by the inner and annulus gases to achieve this expansion or contraction.

For instance, the wall stress in an idealized thin-wall sphere is

$$\sigma=\frac{\Delta P r}{2t},$$

where $\Delta P$ is the pressure difference and $r$ and $t$ are the sphere radius and thickness, respectively. The circumferential strain is

$$\varepsilon_x=\varepsilon_y=\frac{(1-\nu)\Delta P r}{2tE},$$

where $\nu$ is the sphere material's Poisson ratio.

The corresponding strain energy for small strains is


where $V_\mathrm{sphere}=4\pi r^2 t$ is the volume of the sphere material and $E$ is the sphere material's Young's elastic modulus. We'll take the differential form, $$dU_\mathrm{sphere}=2V_\mathrm{sphere}E\varepsilon_x\,d\varepsilon_x=2V_\mathrm{sphere}E\varepsilon_x\,dr\left(\frac{d\varepsilon_x}{dr}\right),$$ and add the pressure–volume terms for the gas:



where $$dV_\mathrm{inner}=d\left(\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3\right)=4\pi r^2\,dr$$


$$dV_\mathrm{annulus}=d\left(V_\mathrm{outer}-\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3\right)=-4\pi r^2\,dr$$

and where I've used Boyle's Law to express the pressures in terms of the original pressure and volumes (with subscript $0$).

Put this all together and minimize $U$ by setting its derivative (with respect to changing $r$) to zero,


and you should then be able to solve for the equilibrium radius $r$. Note that various idealizations and assumptions (such as small strains) have been made throughout this particular toy-model solution, but the concept of energy minimization is a very broad and powerful one.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you! so quick to reply as well, this is exactly what I wanted albeit a bit of reading :) Thanks for the links as well $\endgroup$ Apr 23, 2021 at 23:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.