For an ideal gas of two-component ($A+B$) mixture at a temperature $T$, which expression is correct?

$$p_T=p_A+p_B \tag{1}$$ or $$\rho_T=\rho_A+\rho_B, \tag{2}$$

where $p_T$ and $\rho_T$ are the total pressure and total mass density, respectively. They are useful when defining the molar fraction $x_i$ and mass fraction $\omega_i$ of gas mixture:

$$x_i=\frac{p_i}{p_T}, \quad \omega_i=\frac{\rho_i}{\rho_T} \quad i=A \, \text{or} \, B.$$

If no chemical reaction between the two components, let's assume Eq.(1) is correct firstly. According to the ideal gas law, we have $p_A=\rho_A \frac{R}{M_A}T$ and $p_B=\rho_B \frac{R}{M_B}T$, where $M_A$ and $M_B$ are the molar mass of the two species, $R$ is the universal gas constant. Similarly, for the gas mixture, we have

$$p_T=\rho_T \frac{R}{M_T} T=\frac{\rho_T R T}{x_A M_A+(1-x_A)M_B},$$

where $x_A=p_A/p_T$ is the molar fraction of component $A$ and $M_T$ is the molar mass of the mixture. Substituting $p_A$, $p_B$ and $p_T$ into Eq.(1) and solve for $\rho_T$, we found that

$$\rho_T= (\frac{\rho_A}{M_A}+\frac{\rho_B}{M_B})[x_A M_A+(1-x_A)M_B]. \tag{3}$$

Equation (3) seems to be not consistent with Eq.(2).

I believe Eq.(1) should be correct, which states that the total pressure of an ideal gas mixture is the sum of the partial pressures of the gases in the mixture. I am confusing when I read the prestigious textbook Transport Phenomena by Bird, Stewart & Lightfoot. Here is a screenshot of the related page. enter image description here

I don't know what I am doing wrong in deriving Eq.(3). Can anyone please correct me? Thank you very much!


The formula 2 is not right. You proved it yourself. But you don't need a mathematical proof. Just think about it. If you add a little bit of heavy gas to one tank of hydrogen you get the same density as when you add equal volumes of heavy gas and hydrogen? Density is an example of intensive parameters. Temperature, resistivity, dielectric constant are other examples. The resultant property of the system is not the sum of the properties of the components. It depends on the specific combination of components. Other parameters do add up, like mass, or force and pressure.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you! Please see my update. I understand your explanation but still feel confused with how we defined mass fraction with $\omega_i=\rho_i/\sum_i\rho_i$? Specifically, what is $\rho_i$ exactly? $\endgroup$
    – user55777
    Dec 2 '20 at 6:00
  • $\begingroup$ @user55777 isn’t it just $m_{i}/V$ where $V$ is the total volume of the mixture? $\endgroup$
    – Bob D
    Dec 2 '20 at 11:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.