0
$\begingroup$

I was asked whether weight of a submerged object changes. The following is my current understanding of the matter and will likely contain errors. Please correct me, if I made any mistakes.

Imagine an object with a mass of 1 kg. If you submerge it in water, its apparent weight (not mass, mass stays the same) will be lighter due to buoyancy . (image by Johannes Kalliauer): credit Von Johannes Kalliauer - Auftrieb Archimedes 1.svg, Gemeinfrei, Link

Because force vectors c and d are of the same value, but have a different direction, they annihilate each other. Force vector a has a lower value than vector b, because the hydro static pressure in a depth $H_1$, which acts on the top of the object, is weaker than the hydro static pressure in depth $H_3$, which acts on the bottom of the object. Adding both vectors together yields the vector of upthrust.

Now, moving the submerged object upwards requires less energy compared to moving the same object upwards on land, because by moving the object upwards (positive change in potential energy), water moves downwards to fill the void (negative change in potential energy).

But what if you have a look at a static object on the sea floor? Since it is resting on the seafloor, there will be no more buoyancy. What remains, however, is the gravitational force of the object + the hydro static pressure acting on the top of the object (a).

According to Newton's third law, the sea ground counteracts the sum of both forces (otherwise the object will continue sinking into the ground).


My Problem

What I don't get is, will this object resting on the sea floor result in a change of the object's weight when compared to an object that is affected by buoyancy?

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

Case 1 (practical case): There will almost always be a thin layer of water under the object, and thus the derivation for the buoyant force will still apply.

Case 2 (perfect situation) In special cases when there are no fluids between the object and the ground, then the object will act as a suction cup. Not only will there not be a buoyant force, it will be very difficult to remove it from the ground.

Now - what I don't get: would this (resting object on sea floor) result in a change of the object's weight compared to an object that is affected by buoyancy?

The weight of an object can be defined in many ways. Typically, it refers to $mg$ so as long as the gravitational field does not change, weight will be constant. The weight you are probably referring to is the perceived weight (value of the normal force).

In case 2, the normal force will be greater, as the buoyant force is gone.

$\endgroup$
0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.