Two spaceships A and B are approaching along perpendicular directions, as seen from earth. If A is observed by a stationary Earth observer to have velocity $𝑢_𝑦$ = -0.90c and B to have velocity $𝑢_𝑥$ = +0.90c, determine the speed of ship A as measured by the pilot of ship B.

To solve the problem, I split it into two parts: first part for the $x$ component the velocity of A, and second part for the $y$ component. Let $v$ and $v'$ be the velocities of ship A in frame S and S' respectively. Similarly, let $w$ and $w'$ be the velocities for ship B. We set frame S to be attached to Earth while S' is attached to spaceship B. From Lorentz' velocity transformation formula, $$v_x'=\dfrac{v_x-w_x}{1-\dfrac{v_xw_x}{c^2}}=-w_x=-0.9c$$ since $v_x=0$. Similarly for $v_y$, $$v_y'=\dfrac{v_y-w_y}{1-\dfrac{v_yw_y}{c^2}}=v_y=-0.9c$$ since $w_y=0$. Then I used Pythagoras' Theorem to obtain the total velocity of ship A, and...well here's the result: $v=\sqrt{v_x^2+v_y^2}\approx 1.273c$

At this point, I think my problem clear. As we know, nothing can exceed the speed of light, so it is not possible for ship A to be travelling at a speed higher than $c$. What did I do wrong in my steps? Every example I found online was one-dimensional. I looked for answers on this website, and I found mixed answers more confusing than the problem itself. I'm suspecting that my mistake lies in the assumption that Pythagora's Theorem holds for relativistic velocities. Help, please?


As mentioned by @G.Smith, your second equation is not correct. According to the velocity addition formula, we have:


Remember that the velocity of $B$ shall be considered as $v$ in the above link. $(u_x=v=0.9c)$ Therefore, we can write:


And, finally:

$$u'=\sqrt{u^{\prime 2}_x+u^{\prime 2}_y}=0.982c$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.