I know current is a scalar quantity because it doesn't follow the vector law of addition , but I want to prove it with transformation of coordinates. How to do that? From where to start?


To understand this we need to take a step back and consider what we mean by current. We tend to think a current as that which flows in a wire, but more generally if we have some charge moving in some material then we describe this by a current density, $\mathbf J$, and this is a vector field. Then if we choose some area element $d\mathbf A$ the current through this area is given by the dot product:

$$ dI = \mathbf J \cdot d\mathbf A $$

And to get the total current though a surface we just integrate $dI$ over the surface:

$$ I = \int_S \mathbf J \cdot d\mathbf A $$

So showing that the current is scalar is just a matter of showing that the dot product is not changed by a coordinate transformation. For linear transformations this is obvious because the transformation does not change the norms of the vectors nor the angle between them so $|\mathbf J||d\mathbf A|\cos\theta$ is necessarily constant. I confess I'm not sure how you extend this to a more general transformation.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.