I was studying from Schroeder's thermal physics book. When it talks about Einstein solids it says that they have 2 degrees of freedom thus $U=NkT$

However, I thought when we talk about Einstein solids, we think about harmonic oscillator that oscillates in 3 dimensions. Thus I was expecting Einstein solids to have $U=3NkT$ degree of freedom (3 from position space 3 from momentum space).

What is the correct interpretation of 2 degrees of freedom in Einstein solids?

Note: I might be making a big mistake as I have not taken thermo course in my degree yet, and I am studying all by myself.

Note 2: I know that my approach is flawed as $U=NkT $ result can be obtained from entropy function of Einstein solid. I'm just trying to use Equipartition theorem

  • $\begingroup$ What page are you referring to? $\endgroup$ – BioPhysicist Aug 16 '19 at 22:30
  • $\begingroup$ page can different from edition to edition but it is under chapter 3.2 in the sub-chapter that follows "silly analogy" . In my edition it is page 91 $\endgroup$ – GGphys Aug 16 '19 at 22:34

Each atom is considered to be three oscillators. So each oscillator is actually a 1D oscillator with two degrees of freedom. Therefore, $N$ represents the number of 1D oscillators in the Einstein solid (i.e. there are $N/3$ atoms in the solid). This is explained in chapter 2 of the book.

Therefore, to get to what you were thinking, just use that the number of atoms $n$ relates to the number of oscillators $N$ by $n=N/3$. Therefore we have $$U=NkT=3nkT$$

Note that this doesn't mean that an Einstein solid has two degrees of freedom like you are proposing the book says. Each 1D oscillator (atom) has $2$ ($6$) degrees of freedom. Therefore the entire Einstein solid has $2N$ ($6n$) degrees of freedom.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.