1
$\begingroup$

I've been searching around the internet for a derivation of the guiding wave equation, but I can't find a derivation anywhere. I know that Bohmian Mechanics is not a mainstream idea but I was hoping to learn more about it because no interpretations have been proved in quantum mechanics and this is the most interesting and believable one (to me) so I would like to learn more about this interpretation.

The wave guiding equation is: $$\frac{ \partial Q_k}{\partial t}(t)=\frac{\hbar}{m} \operatorname{Im} \left( \frac{\psi^* \partial_k \ \psi}{\psi^*\psi}(Q_1,...,Q_N,t) \right)$$ So: $$Q_k(t)=\int\frac{\hbar}{m} \operatorname{Im} \left( \frac{\psi^* \partial_k \ \psi}{\psi^*\psi}(Q_1,...,Q_N,t) \right)dt$$

But I don't know where to begin to derive the wave velocity equation. Please can anyone help. Thanks.

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ Have a look here physics.stackexchange.com/q/429767 . Unfortunately Sofia has to be seen since 2018 so will not be seeing any comments/qquestions you make $\endgroup$
    – anna v
    Jul 25 '19 at 4:04
2
$\begingroup$

I've searched around a little more and found a paper deriving the guiding wave equation directly from the strodinger equation. Link: https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/research-centres-and-groups/theoretical-physics/msc/dissertations/2009/Robert-Dabin-Dissertation.pdf

The argument starts from orthodox quantum mechanics and states: $$P=\int_\Gamma d^3r|\Psi|^2$$

Where $\Psi$ is the universal wave function, depends on $(q,t)$ where $\ q \ $ is the collection of starting points for each particle $(\vec{\mu_1}, \vec{\mu_2},...,\vec{\mu_N})$ and follows the universal strodinger equation: $$i\hbar\partial_t \Psi=\sum_{r=1}^N-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m_{r}}\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi+V\Psi$$ If we differentiate $P$ with respect to time and assume the volume of the integral is constant: $$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\frac{d}{dt}\int_\Gamma d^3r|\Psi|^2=\int_\Gamma d^3r\frac{\partial|\Psi|^2}{\partial t}$$ $$|\Psi|^2=\Psi\Psi^\dagger$$ $$\frac{\partial |\Psi|^2}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial}{\partial t}(\Psi\Psi^\dagger)=\Psi^\dagger \frac{\partial \Psi}{\partial t} + \Psi \frac{\partial \Psi^\dagger}{\partial t}$$ Substituting: $$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\frac{d}{dt}\int_\Gamma d^3r|\Psi|^2=\int_\Gamma d^3r \left( \Psi^\dagger \frac{\partial \Psi}{\partial t} + \Psi \frac{\partial \Psi^\dagger}{\partial t} \right) $$ If we solve the strodinger equation for $\partial_t \Psi$ and $\partial_t \Psi^\dagger$ we can substitute this back into the integral: $$i\hbar\partial_t \Psi=\sum_{r=1}^N-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m_{r}}\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi+V\Psi$$ $$\partial_t \Psi=\sum_{r=1}^N-\frac{\hbar^2}{i2m_{r}\hbar}\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi+\frac{V}{i\hbar}\Psi$$ $$\partial_t \Psi=\sum_{r=1}^N\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi-i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi$$ We know: $$\frac{\partial A^\dagger}{\partial F} = \left( \frac{\partial A}{\partial F} \right)^\dagger$$

So: $$\partial_t \Psi^\dagger=\sum_{r=1}^N-\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi^\dagger+i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^\dagger$$

Substituting:

$$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r \left( \Psi^\dagger \left(\sum_{r=1}^N\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi-i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi \right) + \Psi \left( \sum_{r=1}^N-\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi^\dagger+i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^\dagger \right) \right) $$

Factorizing:

$$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N\ \left( \Psi^\dagger \left(\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi-i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi \right) + \Psi \left(-\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi^\dagger+i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^\dagger \right) \right) $$

Distribute $\Psi$ and $\Psi^\dagger$ into the parenthesis: $$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \left( \frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi-i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^{\dagger}\Psi - \frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i \Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi^\dagger+i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^\dagger\Psi \right) $$

$-i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^\dagger\Psi$ and $i\frac{V}{\hbar}\Psi^\dagger\Psi$ cancel and $\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i$ can be factorized to give:

$$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i \left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \partial^{\mu_r}\Psi^\dagger\right) $$

We can factorize out a $\partial^{\mu_r}$: $$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i \partial^{\mu_r}\left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger\right) $$

$$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} \frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i \left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger\right) $$ We are going to name $-\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger\right)$ the current or $j_{\mu_r}$ so when we substitute we get:

$$\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=-\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} j_{\mu_r} $$ Lets substitute $\frac{\partial P}{\partial t}=\int_\Gamma d^3r\frac{\partial|\Psi|^2}{\partial t}$ into the left side of the equation:

$$\int_\Gamma d^3r\frac{\partial|\Psi|^2}{\partial t}$=-\int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} j_{\mu_r} $$

Rearrange: $$\int_\Gamma d^3r\frac{\partial|\Psi|^2}{\partial t} + \int_\Gamma d^3r \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} j_{\mu_r}=0 $$ $$\int_\Gamma d^3r \left( \frac{\partial|\Psi|^2}{\partial t} + \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} j_{\mu_r}\right)=0 $$ Since the region chosen to be integrated is completely arbitrary, the only way to make sure the integral is equal to $0$ is: $$\frac{\partial|\Psi|^2}{\partial t} + \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} j_{\mu_r}=0$$ Lets set $\rho=|\Psi|^2$ (rho is the density): $$\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t} + \sum_{r=1}^N \partial^{\mu_r} j_{\mu_r}=0$$ This is just the continuity equation for a incomprehensible fluid. We know that $j_{\mu_r} = \rho v_{\mu_r}$ so the velocity is: $$v_{\mu_r}=\frac{j_{\mu_r}}{\rho}$$ We can now substitute in the current and density: $$v_{\mu_r}=-\frac{\hbar}{2m_{r}}i\left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger\right)\frac{1}{|\Psi|^2} $$ Rearranging and considering that $-i=\frac{1}{i}$ $$v_{\mu_r}=\frac{1}{2i}\left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger\right)\frac{\hbar}{m_{r}|\Psi|^2} $$ Suppose we have a complex number $z$ and $z = a + ib$. The imaginary part of z is $b$ so $\operatorname{Im}z = b$. If we know $z = a + ib$ then we know its hermissian conjugate $z^\dagger = a - ib$. Lets subtract these two from each-other $z - z^\dagger = 2ib$. Now divide by $2i$, $b = \frac{z - z^\dagger}{2i}$ so $\operatorname{Im} z = \frac{z - z^\dagger}{2i}$. Lets suppose $z = \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi$, its hermissian conjugate is $z^\dagger = \Psi \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger $. If we take $z$ and subtract $z^\dagger$ we get $z - z^\dagger = \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger $ divide by $2i$ and we get $\operatorname{Im}z = \frac{1}{2i} \left( \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi-\Psi\partial_{\mu_r} \Psi^\dagger \right) $. We can substitute this into v_{\mu_r} and we get: $$v_{\mu_r}= \operatorname{Im}(z) \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}|\Psi|^2} $$ $$v_{\mu_r}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}|\Psi|^2} \operatorname{Im}z $$ But we know $z = \Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi$ so if we substitute that we get: $$v_{\mu_r}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}|\Psi|^2} \operatorname{Im}\Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi $$ If we rearrange: $$v_{\mu_r}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}} \operatorname{Im}\frac{\Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi}{|\Psi|^2} $$ We notice $|\Psi|^2 = \Psi\Psi^\dagger$: $$v_{\mu_r}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}} \operatorname{Im}\frac{\Psi^\dagger\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi}{\Psi\Psi^\dagger} $$ We are now left with: $$v_{\mu_r}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}} \operatorname{Im}\frac{\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi}{\Psi} $$ But $v_{\mu_r}=\frac{\partial Q_{\mu_r}}{\partial t}$ So finally: $$\frac{\partial Q_{\mu_r}}{\partial t}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}} \operatorname{Im}\frac{\ \partial_{\mu_r} \Psi}{\Psi} $$ This rank 1 tensor is in L dimensions since $\mu = x = y = z = ... $ and has r amount of particles. If we assume the particles are in 1 dimension the equation boils down to: $$\frac{\partial Q_{x_r}}{\partial t}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}} \operatorname{Im}\frac{\ \partial_{x_r} \Psi}{\Psi} $$ or down to $$\frac{\partial Q_{r}}{\partial t}= \frac{\hbar}{m_{r}} \operatorname{Im}\frac{\ \partial_{x_r} \Psi}{\Psi}$$

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.