0
$\begingroup$
  1. For 2D projectile motion, why is the velocity in the horizontal direction constant?

  2. I learned that we neglect air resistance, but why?

  3. And isn't there horizontal acceleration at the beginning when an object is launched?

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The "projectile motion" that you study when starting dynamics is a simplified version of "real life" which is makes the mathematics easy. By assuming the acceleration due to gravity is constant and ignoring any other forces on the body, you don't even need calculus to set up and solve simplified versions of problems that are at approximations to "real life" scenarios.

Air resistance does not act in the horizontal direction. It acts in the direction of motion of the projectile, so it affects the vertical motion as well as the horizontal. The magnitude of the air resistance force depends on the speed of the projectile, but there is no simple "equation" relating the force to the speed.

Those facts mean that to calculate what happens "in real life," in most situations you can't even find a "mathematical formula" for the answer using calculus - you have to use numerical methods and a computer. Learning how to do that is not the objective of the "projectiles" section of a first dynamics course.

To answer your other question, if you think about it, for the problems you are solving the projectile is not really "launched" at all. It just happens to have a given position and velocity at time zero. What it was doing before time zero is irrelevant to the question.

But you are right that in reality, to launch a projectile from rest you do need to apply a force to it. The magnitude of the force you apply depends on the time it takes to launch the projectile, which in real life can not be "instantaneous". The shorter the time, the bigger the force, but Newton's second law means that the product "average force $\times$ time" is what determines the projectile velocity immediately after it is launched.

So you can simplify the mathematics (again!) by assuming the launch is instantaneous, and finding the amount of "force $\times$ time" which starts the motion. In fact that quantity has its own name, "impulse", and Newton's second law can be stated as "impulse = change of momentum," where momentum is defined to be mass $\times$ velocity.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Okay, I see. But will the approximation be close enough to real life situations? One more clarification, if the launch goes from 0m/s to 50m/s, I would simplify the math by using 50m/s, right? $\endgroup$ – Austin Gae Jul 9 at 23:37
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ It is close enough in a lot of real life situations. But you can't ignore air resistance to find the landing speed of a parachutist, or to understand how a baseball pitcher throws a curve ball, to give two examples (and in the second one, air resistance does not act in the direction of motion of the projectile!) Your statement about how to simplify the math is correct. $\endgroup$ – alephzero Jul 9 at 23:44
0
$\begingroup$

There is no force in the horizontal direction after the projectile is launched, so no acceleration, so no change in horizontal velocity.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Air resistance is a force in the horizontal direction. So yes acceleration, so yes change in horizontal velocity. But I heard we neglect air resistance, but why? Is it negligible? $\endgroup$ – Austin Gae Jul 9 at 23:07
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @Austin For small, reasonably-dense projectiles at modest speeds the air-resistance is pretty negligible (induced acclerations are on the order of centimeters per second, so less than 1% of gee). So the answer is "sometimes". But you are doing that case in class because you have to learn how to understand and apply the framework of mechanics before you start on more complicated problems. By all means be aware that this is an approximation and is not always applicable, but just go with it for now. $\endgroup$ – dmckee Jul 9 at 23:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.