I am stuck in a supposedly simple aspect. Consider the Sun-Earth system. The torque is zero and angular momentum is conserved. $L = I\omega$ is constant, but since $I$ changes, $\omega$ should change as well. That means there is a non-zero angular acceleration.

Now consider $\tau = I\alpha$ which should be zero. Since $I$ can't be zero, angular acceleration must be zero.

I can't explain the apparent contradiction. Your answers would be much appreciated.

  • $\begingroup$ For future reference, please use MathJax to format equations. I have edited your question as an example. $\endgroup$ Jun 25 '19 at 15:57

The problem here is that your system is not a rigid body. We can think of it as a point particle (the Earth) rotating about another point particle (the Sun). The system is not rigid because the distance between these two point particles changes over time. Therefore, we need to be more careful with how we apply these rotational analogs of Newton's laws.

Typically we have: $$\tau=\frac{\text dL}{\text dt}$$ and, for constant $I$ this means: $$\tau=\frac{\text d}{\text dt}\left(I\omega\right)=I\alpha$$

However, as you have pointed out, $I$ is changing, therefore we really have: $$\tau=\frac{\text d}{\text dt}\left(I\omega\right)=\frac{\text dI}{\text dt}\omega+I\alpha$$

Now I won't go into any specific calculations for elliptical orbits (you can do this if you want), but you can see how if the particle is moving inward then $I$ would be decreasing (negative derivative) and the particle would be speeding up (positive $\alpha$), and if the particle is moving away then $I$ would be increasing (positive derivative) and the particle would be slowing down (negative $\alpha$).

The above qualitative argument shows that the two terms in this equation will have opposite sign, and this shows how it could be that these two terms will always cancel out in the orbit to give a net torque of $0$

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, Aaron. That was a great answer and my doubt has been cleared! $\endgroup$
    – Anup Varma
    Jun 27 '19 at 3:24
  • $\begingroup$ @AnupVarma Please upvote any sufficient answers and select an answer to be accepted for future readers. $\endgroup$ Jun 27 '19 at 4:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.