From Polchinski's Vol. 1 Appendix A, we can reduce the Euclidean path integral for the 1D harmonic oscillator to computing $(\det\frac{\Delta}{2\pi})^{-1/2}$ where $$\Delta = -\partial_u^2 + \omega^2.$$

Since $f_j(u) = \sqrt{2/U} \sin(j\pi u/U)$ is an eigenbasis, we compute

$$\det \frac{\Delta}{2\pi} = \prod_{j=1}^{\infty} \frac{j^2\pi^2 + \omega^2 U^2}{2\pi U^2}.$$

Here Polchinski regularizes using Pauli-Villars; he divides by the amplitude for an oscillator with very high frequency $\Omega$ and gets

$$\det \frac{\Delta}{2\pi} \to \prod_{j=1} \frac{j^2 \pi^2 + \omega^2 U^2}{j^2 \pi^2 + \Omega^2 U^2} = \frac{\Omega \sinh \omega U}{\omega \sinh \Omega U}.$$

Now he takes the $\Omega \to \infty$ limit. Why is that the appropriate limit to take at the end?

He obtains $(\det \frac{\Delta}{2\pi})^{-1/2}\approx \left(\frac{\omega}{\sinh\omega U}\right)^{1/2} e^{\frac12(\Omega U - \ln \Omega)}$ and subtracts divergences and gets the right answer. But why is $\Omega \to \infty$ the right limit to take? When we regularize, we typically take a limit at the end to "undo" it. For instance, in QFT we take $d= 4-\epsilon$ and then take $\epsilon \to 0$ at the end.


You’re only interested in the dependence of the determinant on $U$ here (the numeric value for a given $U$ depends on the normalization constant in the functional measure and is therefore unphysical).

The expression for the determinant that you’ve given exhibits $U$-independence for $\omega \rightarrow \infty$ (the $j$-dependent term becomes small compared to the other summand in the numerator, and $U^2$ cancel the $U^2$ in the denominator). Hence, in the limit of infinite frequency you’re dividing by a $U$-independent constant — an operation which is equivalent to redefining the normalization constant. That is no longer true for finite frequencies. Intuitively, setting the frequency to infinity undoes the regularization like you expected.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.