0
$\begingroup$

I don't understand something about boundary conditions in problem that I discuss it below. in QM we solve the particle in Potential well and we obtain that we should have $k=\frac{n*pi}L$ that $n\in{N}$(because negative n don't give new wave function) in statistical physics if we count number of microstates we put 1/8 to count only positive n.but we have another problem say free particle in box of volume V . then the wave function is $(\frac{e^{i\vec k.\vec x}}{\sqrt V})$ and in many books and lectures says Boundary conditions require that the wavevector $\vec k$ should be quantized as $\vec k=\frac{2pi*\vec n}{L}$ and $n\in Z$! and after it calculate the for example Density of States and every things we want in statistical physics.and don't put 1/8 behind their equation!so my problem is what is different between this 2 case that in first $n\in N$ and second $n\in Z$ (but with 2 added to its equation) and then 2 cases give the same physics.is there 2 independent problem or one problem with 2 different of viewpoint?

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

I think, i know the answer. When you take the k space as a sphere,(and you chose your origin in the corner of the container) then you have to include the 1/8 factor. Cause only positive values of n has any meaning. And thus you are counting the 1/8th of a sphere.

But when you take the origin in the center of the container, then you have positive and negative values of n which are valid too. So you have to consider the whole sphere now, not just the 1/8th part. But this time, due to your change in origin, you have a different mathematical form of boundary condition. So the distance between the states changes also. So ultimately the density of state function turns out to be same.

If you still struggling with this, then See Blundell, 21 chapter. There's figure and equation to clarify.

Hope it helps

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ thank for your answer.I think to this that the only different between this 2 case is that how we choice the origin or something more.I talk to some people that they say there are 2 different problem that they are equal in thermodynamics limit and because of it I be confused about it! $\endgroup$ – a.p Jun 12 at 12:01
  • $\begingroup$ I think even we say problem is choice of origin then we most choose positive n because again the negative n dont give the new wave function! $\endgroup$ – a.p Jun 12 at 12:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.