0
$\begingroup$

In this diagram, what do the hyperbola represent. I understand that for a given hyperbola t^2-(x/c)^2 is constant, but in an answer given to this question: What spacelike, timelike and lightlike spacetime interval really mean?

The person writing the answer says "Events on a given hyperbola must, under a given frame boost, remain on that hyperbola". Can someone clarify on this line? How can events be moving positions on space time diagrams? Surely they have a fixed position, and are just read with different numbers based on the coordinate system of the observer moving through it?

enter image description here

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ In that answer, above the diagram, it says "the effect of a frame shift is to slide events around on hyperbolae of constant $\Delta s^2$." So events stay on the same hyperbola when you do a boost. $\endgroup$ – PM 2Ring May 19 at 15:49
  • $\begingroup$ I'm not sure I am reading the diagram correctly. If you take an event that occurs on the orange observers x = 0 axis. It cant also occur at a moving observers x' = 0 axis. Which is what keeping the events on the same hyperbola looks like it does? $\endgroup$ – Vishal Jain May 19 at 16:01
2
$\begingroup$

All points on a given hyperbola are separated from the origin by the same spacetime interval $\Delta s$. We can say that not only is $\Delta s$ frame invariant, so are the hyperbolas.

Let's suppose we have two events, A and B, with A at the origin, $x_A = 0$, $t_A = 0$; and B is at $x_B = 3.0$, $t_B = 5.0$. (Same units for $x$ and $t$. I'm using an example from Thomas A. Moore's book A Traveler's Guide to Spacetime.)

In the $x$-$t$ frame,

$$\left(\Delta s\right)^2 = \left(\Delta t\right)^2 - \left(\Delta x\right)^2 = \left(5.0\right)^2 - \left(3.0\right)^2 = \left(4.0\right)^2.$$

Now consider the $x'$-$t'$ frame, moving at some speed $v$ relative to the $x$-$t$ frame. We assume the $x$-$x'$ axes are parallel, and that the origins of the two frame overlap at event A. We have two options on how to represent the $x'$-$t'$ frame. The first, as shown in your figure, is to draw the $x'$-$t'$ axes on the same diagram with the $x$-$t$ axes. Obviously, nothing already drawn on the figure will change when the $x'$-$t'$ axes are added to the figure, including the hyperbolas and the positions on the figure of the spacetime points A and B.

We can use the hyperbolas to calibrate the scales on the $x'$ and $t'$ axes against the scales on the $x$-$t$ axes, and then we can identify the coordinates of A and B in $x'$-$t'$ system. Suppose that $v$ is such that we get $\Delta x' - 5.0$ and $\Delta t' = 6.4$. (As an exercise, you can work out the value of $v$ from these differences.)

Then, for the $x'$-$t'$ frame, we get

$$\left(\Delta s'\right)^2 = \left(\Delta t'\right)^2 - \left(\Delta x'\right)^2 = \left(6.4\right)^2 - \left(-5.0\right)^2 = \left(4.0\right)^2.$$

The second option is to redraw the figure with the $x'$-$t'$ axes in the normal orientation. The hyperbolas will not change at all because, like $\Delta s$, they are invariants. Neither will the position of event A since it is at the origin in both frames. But the position of event B must change because the $x'$-$t'$ axes are now drawn differently. Since $\Delta x' = -5$ event B will now 'hop' to the left side of the $t'$ axis on the new figure. But it will nevertheless fall onto the same hyperbola as on the original figure.

Why does B fall on the same hyperbola? Because a given hyperbola always represents all points at a common spacetime interval from the origin. Event B is separated from event A by the same $\Delta s$ in all inertial reference frames. It doesn't matter how the axes are drawn. So event B must fall onto precisely the same hyperbola when the figure is redrawn. In addition to hopping to the left of the $t'$ axis, event B has to move toward the top of the figure.

For any value of $v$, we will get $\left(\Delta s\right) = (4)^2.$ If we take event A to define the origin of all possible inertial frames moving with speed $v$ relative to the original $x$-$t$ frame, then event B must fall onto the same hyperbola in all inertial frames. And because the hyperbolas are themselves invariant, we can say B is falling onto literally the same hyperbola in all frames. Adjusting the value of $v$ will do one of two things to the figure, depending on which version of the figure we use.

For the original version, in your post, changing the value of $v$ does not shift the positions of the A and B events on the figure. It causes the $x'$-$t'$ axes to either close in on or open up from the $v = c$ axis. For the alternative version, where the $x'$-$t'$ axes are drawn in the normal orientation (so really we have a new alternative figure for each value of $v$), the point B will slide along $\left(\Delta s\right)^2 = \left(4\right)^2$ hyperbola. So it is in this sense that events can be 'moving' points on a spacetime diagram.

I think you're correct that saying the events 'move' is a little confusing. The events are not moving in a physical sense.

Hope this helps.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.