0
$\begingroup$

Take the Sun as a point object at the origin.

Take the Earth as a sphere centred at $x=d$ with a radius of $R$

Let $d=150,000,000,000$ m

Let $R=6,400,000$ m

Slice the sphere into vertical disks of mass $\Delta m$

The force on each disk will be $\frac{k\Delta m}{x^2}$ where $k=GM_{Sun}$

The total force will be $F=k\int^{d+R}_{d-R} \frac{\Delta m}{x^2}$

Assume the Earth has a constant density.

Let the mass of the entire Earth be $m$

$$\frac{\Delta m}{volume-of-disk}=\frac{m}{volume-of-earth}$$

$$\frac{\Delta m}{\pi y^2 \Delta x}=\frac{m}{\frac{4}{3}\pi R^3}$$

$$\Delta m = \frac{3my^2}{4R^3} \Delta x$$

$$F=\frac{3km}{4R^3}\int^{d+R}_{d-R} \frac{y^2}{x^2} \delta x$$

Let's deal with the $y^2$ now.

$$R^2=y^2+(d-x)^2$$

$$y^2=R^2-d^2+2dx-x^2$$

$$\frac{y^2}{x^2}=\frac{R^2-d^2}{x^2}+\frac{2d}{x}-1$$

So the force is now: $$F=\frac{3km}{4R^3}\int^{d+R}_{d-R} (\frac{R^2-d^2}{x^2}+\frac{2d}{x}-1) \delta x$$

$$F=\frac{3km}{4R^3} [\frac{d^2-R^2}{x}+2d \ln{|x|}-x]^{d+R}_{d-R}$$

$$F=\frac{3km}{2R^3}(d\ln{|\frac{d+R}{d-R}|}-2R)$$

If the force of gravity is acting on a point at location $x=r$ then the force $F$ is also given by: $$F=\frac{km}{r^2}$$

So:

$$F=\frac{km}{r^2}=\frac{3km}{2R^3}(d\ln{|\frac{d+R}{d-R}|}-2R)$$

$$F=\frac{1}{r^2}=\frac{3}{2R^3}(d\ln{|\frac{d+R}{d-R}|}-2R)$$

Now when I sub in $R=6400000$ and $d=150000000000$ I expect to get a value for $r$ slightly less than $d$ , but I don't get this result. In fact the value of what is in the bracket turns out to be negative: $-0.003868$. Have I done something wrong in my derivation ?

$\endgroup$

closed as off-topic by Aaron Stevens, John Rennie, Kyle Kanos, ZeroTheHero, Jon Custer Feb 19 at 15:46

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

  • "Homework-like questions should ask about a specific physics concept and show some effort to work through the problem. We want our questions to be useful to the broader community, and to future users. See our meta site for more guidance on how to edit your question to make it better" – Aaron Stevens, John Rennie, Kyle Kanos, ZeroTheHero, Jon Custer
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • $\begingroup$ Are you ignoring the fact that the field lines converge for $y \ne 0$? Shouldn't that effect be the same magnitude as the distance dependence? $\endgroup$ – JEB Feb 18 at 21:32
  • $\begingroup$ @JEB I don't know what that means JEB. Could you rephrase that , or dumb it down for me please ? $\endgroup$ – Kantura Feb 18 at 21:38
  • $\begingroup$ If you assume the Earth has a spherically-symmetric mass density, then you should find that the Sun’s gravitational force is effectively acting on the center of the Earth. $\endgroup$ – G. Smith Feb 19 at 1:35
1
$\begingroup$

The Sun's gravity is stronger (weaker) at the near (far) side with respect to the center (along the center line, $y=z=0$). If you find the center of gravity of that:

$$ x_{cg} = \frac{\int_{x=-R}^{x=R}{x\frac{G\rho(x)}{(d+x)^2}dx}}{\int_{x=-R}^{x=R}{\frac{G\rho(x)}{(d+x)^2}dx}} < 0 $$

(where I moved the origin to the center of the Earth), that is going to be closer to the Sun than the center of mass:

$$ x_{cm} = \frac{\int_{x=-R}^{+R}{x\rho(x)dx}} {\int_{x=-R}^{x=R}{\rho(x)dx}}=0$$

which is what you were trying to do.

You can estimate the difference in the force at each end from

$$F(x) \approx F(0) + \frac{dF}{dx}(x) = F(0)[1-\frac{2x}{d}] $$

so

$$ F(\pm R) = F(0)[1\mp \frac{2R}d] $$

or

$$ \frac{\Delta F} F = \frac{2R} d $$

for a shift of 1 radius.

The problem is that when you get off the center line, the fields are not parallel, they all point inward towards the center of the sun. Though transverse components cancel by symmetry, the longitudinal component is reduced.

You can estimate by how much:

$$ F(x=0, y=R) \approx F(0)\cos{\frac R d} = F(0)[1-\frac 1 2 (\frac R d)^2] $$

which seems insignificant compared with longitudinal tidal effect because it is quadratic in the small parameter (versus linear).

But: It applies to much more of the mass, since it covers the whole ring and not just the end points (that takes care of 1 power of $R/d$) and the transverse effect has the same magnitude as the longitudinal effect (and thus, the tidal tensor is traceless).

You will have to generalize the 1st formula for $x_{cg}$ to include 3 dimensions (with cylindrical symmetry) to discover the correct answer.

The correct answer is that the force acts as if all the mass is at the center of the Earth--for a spherically symmetric Earth. If there is a quadruple moment (c.f., $J_2$), then it couples to the tensor gradient of the gravitational field to create torques and move centers-of-gravity, but spherically symmetric Earths have no higher order moments.

$\endgroup$

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.