1
$\begingroup$

On the internet they list ways to calculate weights based on CG when there is a weight on the left and on the right of your CG.

Basic CG

Most of the examples show a box truck for determining the weight on the axles.

How would you determine weight when there are 3 points rather than two. I tried looking up how to determine the weights on the axles of a semi-tractor and trailer, but the weight of the front axle seems to always be known.

Including B and C

I would like to suspend this load using springs. So points A, B, and C would be springs in this case. How can I determine the weight on each spring?

The internet seems to have almost nothing beyond the simple A/B example.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

The top example is statically determinate. With knowledge of the distances from A and B to the CG you can take the the sum of the moments of A and B about the CG and set to 0. Then sum of the vertical forces $-CG+F_A+F_B=0$ gives you two equations and two unknowns to enable you to solve for the forces at A and B.

For the bottom example, the additional reaction force at C gives you a redundant reaction force to the CG and makes the problem statically indeterminate. It becomes a mechanics of materials problem requiring analysis of the deformations of the three springs and information on the distances between A, B and C with respect the CG and some assumptions about the truck body (e.g., is it rigid, is it to remain level).

Hope this helps.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Consider converting a simple two-support problem to a mysterious three-support problem.

Suppose you have the load in your diagram supported by $A$ and $B$. The solution is simple: $A+B$ must equal the load, and the total moment of the three forces ($A$, $B$, and $\text{Load}$) about any point must be zero. Two equations, two unknowns, no problem: a single, unique solution.

Now suppose you decide that the two supports may not be up to the task, and decide to shove another support, $C$, in to help.

So you stick $C$ in, and use jacks or wedges to raise it up to take part of the load. But you can stop wherever you want!

You can just lightly wedge $C$ in, or you can keep pounding away until $B$ is relieved of almost all of its load.

Both of these extremes, and everything in between constitutes a valid solution to the question of the value for $A$, $B$ and $C$.

Two equations, three unknowns: no unique solution.

In the real world, the bed of the truck will flex, the three supports will compress slightly and the load will be shared. But a simple change in temperature with the attendant thermal expansion of the three load-bearing points, would change this.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.