I was recently reading the Nobel lecture by Feynman, and there he talks about this idea of fields interacting with itself. Now according to classical theory interaction with itself imply r=0 and since force is 1/r^2, then F= infinity.

Are there any ways we can understand this type of interaction? Is this idea completely discarded by physicists in all possible theory ever existed?

  • "Is this idea completely discarded by physicists in all possible theory ever existed?" Quite the contrary. Self interaction is essential to field theory. – my2cts 2 days ago

Yes. Here are six examples, four in quantum field theory and two in General Relativity.

In the Standard Model, the Higgs particle, the gluons, and the W and Z bosons all have self-interactions. They can be “renormalized” to handle the infinities. Self-interactions are an intrinsic feature of nob-abelian gauge theories.

In General Relativity, a point charge at rest outside a black hole experiences a finite electrostatic self-force away from the hole. And General Relativity is nonlinear so gravity by itself is a self-interacting theory.

All particles have self interaction. A particle cannot have a field without a self interaction term in its Lagrangian.

  • 2
    In quantum field theory, a quadratic kinetic term is not considered a self-interaction. There are fields, such as the electromagnetic field, which have a quadratic kinetic term but whose interactions are only with other fields (i.e., those corresponding to charged particles). Similarly, quarks do not interact directly with quarks, electrons do not interact directly with electrons, etc. – G. Smith 2 days ago
  • @G. Smith I should clarify. By selfinteraction I mean the interaction of a particle with its own e. g. electromagnetic field. – my2cts 2 days ago
  • @my2cts The term "self-interaction" means that you'd have a term in the Lagrangian that is of order cubic or higher in the same field, for example for gauge bosons in non-Abelian gauge theory, where you have cubic and quartic (self) couplings of the gauge boson. Also, if in your last comment 'particle' means electron and 'electromagnetic field' means the Maxwell field, then the interaction is described by the primitive QED vertex term $e \bar{\psi} \gamma^\mu \psi A_\mu$ in the Lagrangian. This is not a self-interaction term; it tells you how the photon couples to fermions. – Avantgarde yesterday
  • @Avantgarde This term also implies that an electron interacts with itself via its own field, which is self-interaction. – my2cts yesterday
  • @my2cts The terminology as it is used today does not call the electron-photon-electron interaction term as the "self-interaction" of the electron field. – Avantgarde 22 hours ago

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.