When one models the early universe it is most often assumed to be in thermal equilibrium i.e. the entropy is maximized and therefore constant $$dS=0$$

As far as I understand this can be explained as follows:

The change of entropy with Volume is given as: $$\frac{\partial S}{\partial V}=\frac{1}{T}\frac{\partial U}{\partial V}$$

therefore if we model a part of the early universe as a closed box of Volume $V_0$ with internal Energy $U_0$ we find $$\frac{\partial U}{\partial V}=0$$ and therefore $$\frac{\partial S}{\partial V}=0$$

i.e. as the Universe expands the entropy stays constant.

(One could also argue that a thermal equilibrium can be defined as the entropy being maximized and ignore the above...)

However, if we take a look at the Einstein equation including the cosmological constant $\Lambda$ $$G^{\mu\nu}=\frac{8\pi G}{c^4}T^{\mu\nu}-\Lambda g^{\mu\nu}$$ The cosmological constant is often interpreted as additional stress energy tensor i.e. we define the total tensor $$T^{'\mu\nu}=T^{\mu\nu}-\Lambda g^{\mu\nu}$$ with a new energy density $$T^{'00}=\rho-\Lambda$$ if we assume a perfect fluid with energy density $\rho$ Now the volume can be defined in terms of the scale paramter $a$ as $$V=V_0a^3$$ such that $\rho\propto a^{-3}$ i.e. $$\rho=\rho_0a^{-3}$$ $\Lambda$ however is just a constant. Therefore the overall energy $$U=\int dV\,\,T^{'00}$$ is no longer constant in $a$ and therefore $$dS\neq 0$$

Probably I got a mistake in this somewhere but I don't see it. I guess its either

1) my assumption taking the cosmological constant into account is not valid or

2)I got some basics of thermodynamics wrong...

I would be glad if someone could show me where my mistake(s) is(are).


The thermodynamic equilibrium requires a maximum entropy, hence $dS = 0$ by definition.

However in your demonstration there are inconsistencies.

I part of your post
The first law of thermodynamics states $\delta Q = dU + p dV$. If the process is reversible you have $dS = \delta Q / T$ and you can write $dS = (1 / T) (dU + p dV)$.
If we consider as state variables $T$ and $V$, we have $dS = (\partial S / \partial T) dT + (\partial S / \partial V) dV$. Comparing with above $\partial S / \partial T = (1 / T) (\partial U / \partial T)$ and $\partial S / \partial V = (1 / T) (\partial U / \partial V + p)$.
It is not the expression in your post.

II part of your post
$T^{00} = \rho + \Lambda$ with a $+$ sign as $g^{00} = -1$
$\rho_{matter} \propto a^{-3}$
$\rho_{radiation} \propto a^{-4}$
$\rho_{\Lambda} \propto a^0$
Your statement about density refers to matter density only, which is not the case in the early universe anyway.
The energy conservation law for the cosmological fluid gives
$\partial_t (\rho a^3) + p \partial_t (a^3) = 0$
The first term is the rate of change of the energy in a volume defined by the comoving coordinates. It is not zero unless the pressure is nil, but the pressure is not. In fact while $p_{matter}$ is negligible, $p_{radiation} = (1/3) \rho_{radiation}$ and $p_{\Lambda} = - \rho_{\Lambda}$.

General comment
Being the universe thermally isolated, as by definition there are no external systems, the entropy can only either increase if the processes are irreversible or stay constant if reversible (thermal equilibrium).

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.