Ok, my understanding of physics is still limited, hoping to change that in the following years, but I have a question.

Dark energy is what provokes the expansion of the universe, so, in theory, it must be exerting some kind of "anti-gravity", definitely an energy as I see it.

Would it be possible to turn dark energy into usable, electric energy? For example, using a piezoelectric sensor?

I think if we found a way to do that, we would provide the world with infinite, free energy. Forever.

  • $\begingroup$ Notice that dark energy is what provokes the acceleration of the expansion of the universe, not the expansion of the universe. $\endgroup$ – Charo Jul 17 '14 at 10:17

The question Qmechanic linked to is a duplicate, but I think the answer to that question is wrong. Well, actually it's only technically wrong since there is no practical way to extract useful energy from dark energy, but in principle it could be done.

If you tie two spheres to each end of a rope and leave them floating in space then the expansion of space will produce a force pulling the rope tight. If you have some form of generator at the centre of the rope you could turn this tension into electricity and generate power from the expansion. Since dark energy accelerates the expansion you would be generating electrictly (partly) from dark energy.

But I must emphasise that the power you could generate in this way is absurdly small on any scale less than the intergalactic, and it could never be a useful way to provide us with electricity. So despite my reasoning above the answer to your question is really no.

  • $\begingroup$ I thought it was quite small on intergalactic scales as well? From what I understand the size has to be of the scale of the universe (0.5, or 0.3) to get significantly stronger than gravity? $\endgroup$ – Kitchi Dec 10 '12 at 13:40
  • $\begingroup$ I agree with your answer, but you cannot extract energy from a constant force, you need a force acting over a distance which is why I wrote my answer that points out the need for a lengthening rope... $\endgroup$ – FrankH Dec 10 '12 at 14:10
  • $\begingroup$ @FrankH: look at the de-sitter solution in Schwarzschild coordinates, which would be appropriate for a stationary central observer--the force isn't constant. $\endgroup$ – Jerry Schirmer Dec 10 '12 at 14:48
  • $\begingroup$ @jerryschrimer it doesn't matter if a force is constant or not, the only way to get energy is to have a force act over a distance. $\endgroup$ – FrankH Dec 10 '12 at 15:06
  • $\begingroup$ @FrankH yes I agree. Work is obviously force times distance so you need to pay out the rope to extract any energy. But no-one is seriously suggesting this is a practical way to generate power. $\endgroup$ – John Rennie Dec 10 '12 at 15:13

The universe is expanding at 74 km/sec/Mpc (Mpc is a mega parsec which is 3.26 million light years). So let's take two heavy objects and place them far from any galaxy cluster or other influence and space them just one parsec apart (3.26 light years). Then they will effectively be moving apart at 7.4 km/sec. Now imagine that you have a monomolecular filament rope between the objects that puts a force on the objects that will decelerate the objects. Then during the time that they are decelerating you can extract work from the objects. That work per second comes from the force the rope is exerting being applied over the 7.4 cm/sec that the objects are moving apart. However, once the force causes their relative velocity to drop to 0, you won't be able to get any more energy from the objects since they are no longer moving apart. There will still be a constant force on your rope but you need to have a force applied over a distance to get work.

Now this is all from just the "Big Bang" expansion of space. Once the rope's force has gotten their relative velocity to zero, the two objects are like a gravitational bound system and it will stop "expanding". However, in addition to the "standard" expansion of space, we now know that there is dark energy which is causing an accelerating expansion of the universe. This means that the two objects are not just "moving" apart at constant 7.4 cm/sec but that this velocity is actually increasing with time. So if you setup your rope such that the force it is exerting on the objects results in an deceleration that is slightly smaller than this cosmic acceleration, you can extract work continuously and indefinitely. Unfortunately, I have not been able to convert the dark energy measurements into units of acceleration in this particular case of objects at one parsec. I suspect it is a small number but current estimates are that it is definitely positive. Note that if your rope exerts more force that causes a deceleration larger than the cosmic acceleration then the objects will eventually stop moving apart and the work you can extract will drop to zero again.

Note that from just the normal expansion of the universe you can only extract a finite total amount of energy, but that with the accelerated expansion you can extract a small but positive amount of energy per second forever. However, your rope needs to get longer and longer with time (at the rate of 7.4 cm/sec, in this example), so, as they say TANSTAFL (there ain't no such thing as a free lunch). The rope needs to get longer because you have to have your very small force applied to continuously moving objects to get work done. Since it will take continuous energy to make a continuously lengthening rope, and you cannot win this battle by starting with objects that are further apart since then the rope is lengthening at an even faster rate than the 7.4 cm/sec of this example. You can increase the energy per second you extract by making the objects more massive, but then the force on the rope increases so you need to make a thicker rope.

The bottom line is that I think this free energy project is impractical, even though it is theoretically possible. The problem that needs to be solved is the energy cost of the continuously lengthening rope.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ It's not possible, even in theory -- eventually they would vanish over each other's deSitter horizons. This is a lot like trying to extract energy by lowering something by rope into a black hole. There is of course the practical problem of having a rope that can hold something just above the event horizon, sure. But ignoring that, once you hit the event horizon, that's it, you can't extract any more energy, even in theory. $\endgroup$ – Retarded Potential Jan 9 '13 at 18:27
  • $\begingroup$ @SpacelikeCadet OK, so it won't last forever, but it theoretically would produce energy for a very long time. But of course it is impossible in any practical sense in the first place. $\endgroup$ – FrankH Jan 9 '13 at 18:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.