Average velocity is defined as: $\vec{\Delta v} = \frac{\vec{\Delta r}}{\Delta t}$, and average acceleration as $\vec{\Delta a} = \frac{\vec{\Delta v}}{\Delta t}$.

It is apparant from these definitions that average velocity, average acceleration and displacement all have the same direction, but I have got stuck in this:

Assume that we are studying the motion of a particle in one dimension:
Let $\Delta t = 1s$, $\vec{v_i} = -4 \hat{\textbf{i}} m/s$ and $\vec{v_f} = -2 \hat{\textbf{i}} m/s$.
Hence, $\vec{\Delta v} = 2 \hat{\textbf{i}} m/s$ and $\vec{\Delta a} = 2 \hat{\textbf{i}}$, so both of average-velocity's and average-acceleration's direction are toward the positive $x$-axis, but surely the displacement will be toward the negative $x$-axis since both velocity values are toward the negative $x$-axis. Is what I have guessed right?


You are on the right track, but $\Delta\vec{v}$ is not average velocity. It's just the change in velocity:

$$\Delta\vec{v} = \vec{v_f} - \vec{v_i} \neq \frac{\Delta \vec{r}}{\Delta t}.$$

For your example, find $\Delta\vec{r}$ from a kinematic equation:

$$\Delta\vec{r} = \vec{v_i}\Delta t + \frac{1}{2}\vec{a}\Delta t^2 .$$

With your numbers, $\Delta \vec{r} = -3\hat{i}$ m, and $\vec{v}_{avg} = \frac{\Delta \vec{r}}{\Delta t} = -3\hat{i} \frac{\textrm{m}}{\textrm{s}}$.


The displacement can be positive while $\vec v$ and $\vec a$ are negative. Imagine a car going from $x=10$ to a streetlight at $x=0$. At every $t$ the displacement is positive since the car is always on the $x>0$ side. However surely $\vec v$ is negative since the displacement is from $x=10$ towards $x=0$, i.e. while $\vec r$ is positive, $\Delta \vec r$ is negative.

Moreover, in the case of 1d motion, it is entirely possible to have constant negative acceleration yet positive or negative velocities. This is best captured by the equation $$ v(t)=v_0-a t\, ,\qquad a>0 $$ so that, if - say - the initial velocity $v_0= 10m/s$ while $a=5m/s^2$, we find that between $0\le t\le 2$, the velocity is positive while for $t>2$ the velocity is negative. Of course, because $v(t)$ changes sign during the motion, there will be time intervals where $\Delta \vec r>0$ and times when $\Delta \vec r<0$ since the equation for position as a function of time is (in 1d) $$ x(t)=x_0+v_0t-\frac{1}{2}at^2= x_0+10 t -\frac{5}{2}t^2\, , $$ which will be positive (for $x_0=0$) for small $t$ but negative for larger $t$, i.e. the object will pass through $x=0$ at $t=0$ and $t=4$.

Actually one should not think that both $\Delta \vec v$ and $\Delta \vec a$ need to be in the same direction or even co-linear. Think of circular motion: then clearly the average velocity is (for sufficiently short times) nearly tangent to the circle but the average acceleration will be directly basically towards the centre of the circle.

A simple example is provided assuming the Moon is in circular motion about the Earth. Clearly the force $\vec F_{ME}$ will be co-linear with the acceleration but obviously here this acceleration is not in the same direction as the velocity. enter image description here


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.