Griffiths defines Feynman amplitude for the CC process $\nu_\mu + e \rightarrow \mu + \nu_e$ as

$$\mathscr{M} = \frac{ g_w^2}{8M_W^2} \left[\bar \nu_e \gamma^\mu (\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) e\right] \left[\bar \mu \gamma_\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) \nu_\mu\right]$$

When we want $|\mathscr{M}|^2$ the complex conjugate is multiplied as

$$\sum_\text{spins} |\mathscr{M}|^2 = \frac{ g_w^4}{64M_W^4} \left[\bar \nu_e \gamma^\mu (\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) e\right] \left[\bar \mu \gamma_\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) \nu_\mu\right] \left[\bar \nu_e \gamma^\mu (\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) e\right]^* \left[\bar \mu \gamma_\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) \nu_\mu\right]^*$$

where the particle symbols are spinors. My question starts now: using Casimir's trick I found

\begin{equation} \begin{split} \left<|\mathscr{M}|^2 \right> = \left(\frac{g_w}{4 M_W}\right)^4 &Tr[\gamma^\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) (\displaystyle{\not}{p_e} + \mathbb{m_e}) {\gamma^0}(\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) {\gamma^\nu}^{\dagger} {\gamma^0} \displaystyle{\not}{p}_{\nu_e}]\\ &Tr[\gamma_\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) \displaystyle{\not} {p}_{\nu_\mu} {\gamma^0}(\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) {\gamma_\nu}^\dagger{\gamma^0} (\displaystyle{\not}{p}_{\mu} + \mathbb{m_\mu})] \end{split} \end{equation}

but Griffths's solution is

\begin{equation} \begin{split} \left<|\mathscr{M}|^2 \right> = \left(\frac{g_w}{4 M_W}\right)^4 &Tr[\gamma^\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) (\displaystyle{\not}{p_e} + \mathbb{m_e}) {\gamma^\nu}(\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) \displaystyle{\not}{p}_{\nu_e}]\\ &Tr[\gamma_\mu (\mathbb{1}-\gamma^5) \displaystyle{\not} {p}_{\nu_\mu}{\gamma_\nu}(\mathbb{1} -\gamma^5) (\displaystyle{\not}{p}_{\mu} + \mathbb{m_\mu})] \end{split} \end{equation}

Can anybody help me to understand the possible mistake? Thanks in advance.


The results are the same. Since

$$\big\{ \gamma^{\mu\dagger},\gamma^5 \big\} = 0$$


$$\gamma^0\gamma^{\mu\dagger}\gamma^\mu = \gamma^\mu$$

you obtain

$$\gamma^0(1 - \gamma^5)\gamma^{\mu\dagger}\gamma^0 = \gamma^0\gamma^{\mu\dagger}(1 + \gamma^5)\gamma^0 = \gamma^0\gamma^{\mu\dagger}\gamma^0(1 - \gamma^5) = \gamma^{\mu}(1 - \gamma^5).$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.