Will we see or can we measure Cherenkov radiation in media different from pure water?

It is well known that Cherenkov radiation is observable by bare eye in nuclear pools. But if we replace water with ethanol, let's say, can we expect to see this radiation?

I tried to find some papers on this subject but without success. If you can provide me with them or give the links, I will greatly appreciate that.


You will get Cerenkov radiation in any (transparent) dielectric where the phase velocity of the light waves is smaller than the velocity of charged particles traversing it. You will definitely see Cerenkow radiation with fast enough charged particles in ethanol, which has a similar (only a little higher) refractive index as water.


A particle passing through a material at a velocity greater than that at which light can travel through the material emits light. This is similar to the production of a sonic boom when an airplane is traveling through the air faster than sound waves can move through the air. The direction this light is emitted is on a cone with angle θc about the direction in which the particle is moving, with cos(θc) = c/nv (c = the vacuum speed of light, n = the refractive index of the medium, and v is the speed of the particle). The angle of the cone θc thus is a direct measure of the particle's speed.

If the momentum of the particle is known, as in tracking detectors, one can get at the mass of the particle. Gases aerogels and quarz have been used for detecting the radiation.

High energy physics has been using cherenkov radiation detectors since the LEP experiment Delphi, the material just needs to be transparent with index of refraction larger than 1, for particle identification. The momentum of the particles is found in tracking detectors and the angle of radiation gives the mass:

The ring-imaging Cherenkov, or RICH, detector is a device for identifying the type of an electrically charged subatomic particle of known momentum, that traverses a transparent refractive medium, by measurement of the presence and characteristics of the Cherenkov radiation emitted during that traversal. RICH detectors were first developed in the 1980s and are used in high energy elementary particle- , nuclear- and astro-physics experiments.


The different particle types follow distinct contours of constant mass, smeared by the effective angular resolution of the RICH detector; at higher momenta each particle emits a number of Cherenkov photons which, taken together, give a more precise measure of the average $θ_c$ than does a single photon, allowing effective particle separation to extend beyond 100 GeV in this example.

  • $\begingroup$ It might be worth expanding this to explicitly indicate the Cerenkov detectors (both ring imaging and simple threshold devices) are regularly built using gas, liquid, areogel, and solid radiators. $\endgroup$ – dmckee --- ex-moderator kitten Feb 1 '18 at 1:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.