In problem 3.35 of Griffiths' Introduction to electrodynamics, he states:

A solid sphere, radius $R$, is centered at the origin. The “northern” hemisphere carries a uniform charge density $\rho_0$, and the “southern” hemisphere a uniform charge density $−\rho_0$. Find the approximate field $E(r,θ)$ for points far from the sphere ($r \gg R$).

The dipole moment is by definition

$$\textbf{p}=\iiint \textbf{r}'\rho(\textbf{r}') \;\mathrm{dV}$$

But Griffiths uses $z=r'\cos \theta$ and says

$$\textbf{p}=\iiint \textbf{z}\rho(\textbf{r}') \;\mathrm{dV}$$

How does this work? Aren't you supposed to use $r'$ in the integral?

In my calculations I get

$$\textbf{p}= \iiint_\text{northern hemisphere} \textbf{r}'\rho_0 \;\mathrm{dV} -\iiint_\text{southern hemisphere} \textbf{r}'\rho_0\;\mathrm{dV}$$

which gives $$\textbf{p}=0$$

when evaluated, which is wrong. Where have I setup my integral wrong?


Remember that the dipole moment is a vector quantity! The definition of the electric dipole moment is: $$ \mathbf p = \int_{\Bbb R^3}\mathbf x \rho(\mathbf x) d^3\mathbf x $$ Now plug in in $\mathbf x =\rho\ \hat\rho+z\hat k$ and use cylindrical coordinates. $$\mathbf p =\int_{\Bbb R^3} \rho \, \hat \rho \; \rho(\mathbf x) d^3\mathbf x + \hat k\int_{\Bbb R^3} z \rho(\mathbf x) d^3\mathbf x$$ Since the volume charge density is independent of $\phi$ (azimuthal symmetry), $\rho(\mathbf x) = \mathcal p(z,\rho)$, where $\mathcal p$ is some arbitrary function , and the first integral vanishes: $$\int_{\Bbb R^3} \rho \, \hat \rho \; \rho(\mathbf x) d^3\mathbf x =\int_{0}^{2\pi} d\phi(\cos\phi \hat i+\sin\phi \hat j) \int_z\int_\rho dz \ d\rho \ \rho \; \mathcal p(z,\rho) =0$$ Thus, only the integral on z remains, which is the one Griffiths is using: $$\mathbf p =\hat k\int_{\Bbb R^3} z \rho(\mathbf x) d^3\mathbf x=\hat k\int_0^{2 \pi}d\phi \ [ \ \rho_0\int_0^{\pi/2} \int_0^R dr d\theta\ r^2 \sin\theta \ (r \cos\theta) \ -\rho_0\int_{\pi/2}^{3\pi/2} \int_0^R dr d\theta\ r^2 \sin\theta \ (r \cos\theta) \ ] $$ This gives: $$\mathbf p = 2 \pi \rho_0\hat k \ (\frac 14 R^4)(\int_0^{\pi/2} [ \ (\frac12)\sin(2\theta)\ d\theta -\int_{\pi/2}^{3\pi/2} (\frac12)\sin(2\theta)\ d\theta \ ] $$ $$\mathbf p = 2 \pi \rho_0\hat k \ (\frac 14 R^4)(\frac12 - 0)$$ Finally: $$\mathbf p = \frac \pi 4 \rho_0 R^4\hat k$$

  • $\begingroup$ i edited my question because i dont know how to use symbols in the comments, so please see my edited question. $\endgroup$ – hola Nov 17 '17 at 8:42
  • $\begingroup$ You are crossing out integrals with different integration regions! Check my edited answer. $\endgroup$ – Sahand Tabatabaei Nov 17 '17 at 16:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.